Our official scale of balloon brands and types

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Thinskinned
    Look Out!
    • Jul 2024
    • 247

    #16
    I love the Belbal 14". sometimes it feels a bit too small but I like how it's bigger than a 12" while still being manageable. I also really like how well they neck out, it gets really big and full very easily. I really wish the Belbal 17" had such a nice big neck.

    I've started to dislike tuftex a bit -- a lot of the TT17s I've blown up recently have had these large crystal-looking imperfections on the bulb, I've had a crystal pop on second inflation, had a few standards pop very prematurely as well and now they feel untrustworthy to me.

    Comment

    • Golden
      I'm whatca need
      • Jun 2022
      • 483

      #17
      Originally posted by Thinskinned
      I've started to dislike tuftex a bit -- a lot of the TT17s I've blown up recently have had these large crystal-looking imperfections on the bulb, I've had a crystal pop on second inflation, had a few standards pop very prematurely as well and now they feel untrustworthy to me.
      sounds like your getting bad batches. I've had no issue with pre-inflation and inflating them on the 2nd go. Although I do notice some defects now and then but they appear to be cosmic as so far none have popped on me.
      my lament of longing
      This is now my only choice
      My shadowed heart is lonely
      I can't seem to find my voice
      ​

      Comment

      • nonpop
        Soft balloons first
        • Jul 2024
        • 104

        #18
        Gone through all the links and comments
        I have now gone through all of the links above and all the comments. I have updated the table in the first post in this thread with everything I found, basically confirming the table from Scooter and adding a few brands to the list. There was a lot to go through and a lot of competence. However, what does not stand out as clear for almost everthing I've read is how some balloons are compared to other brands. People usually say things like "This brand are very strong". This is where the new list will shine. Also a lot of people tend to like the same brands, that are already on the list.

        Adding new brands
        I have also gone throgh the list of brands I could find at the established well-known balloon stores online and added all the brands to my list. However I don't want these brands to go in the first post list before we have at least some data on strength and/or stiffness. I'll add my (so far) complete list of brands as an inspiration to the ones of you with experience with a few of the brands lacking data:
        Brand Strength Stiffness Comment Brand site
        Sempertex 9 7
        Balloonia 9 4
        Belbal 8 8
        Tuftex 8 4
        Amscan 7 7
        BWS / Rifco 7
        Art Show 7 5
        Qualatex 6 6
        Decomex 5 5 18" stuffing (Wide neck) especially strong. Not as strong as Qualatex? https://www.decomexballoon.com/
        Cattex 5 6
        Gemar 5 8 19" are specially strong. https://gemar.it/
        Unique/Globos Payaso 4 3
        BSA
        Deepak Rubbers
        Feng Che https://www.aloballoons.com/
        Jarty Party
        Xiaobo Balloons
        Gummiwerk Czermak & Feger https://www.gummiwerk.at/
        Kalisan https://kalisanballoon.com/
        Everts Mentioned to be solid. Assuming stronger than Qualatex, so a 7? https://www.everts.com.my/
        BK latex https://www.bklatex.com/
        Prima https://www.primaballoons.com/
        Sorted order
        Notice also that I've added the bands descending based on strenght. My guess is that most of you will be interesting in exactly that (though myself will go for softness/stiffness). And this should be able to start some arguments or evaluations of this data for most of you - and we need those inputs!

        If your general experience is that Rifco balloons are stronger or weaker than Art show balloons, we should adjust the value for those.

        So here's some home work
        Look at the table above and consider the following:
        • Should any brand be moved up or down the list?
        • I think we'll be able to avoid two brands with the exact same number - unless people start to disagree (or the brand are simply generally poor so one cares about them anyway)
        • We can add decimals to differentiate where needed.
        • Do you experience with any of the brands that don't have data? Compare them with the others and give a rating.

        Comment

        • Scooter
          風船天才
          • May 2022
          • 497

          #19
          Regarding Rifco/BWS, I have experience with that brand as well, but only in the 40" size, so I don't know if this is consistent with smaller versions.

          That being said, I'd move them down to a 6 in strength to be even with Q-tex, and I'd put their stiffness at a 5. Gave me a similar feeling to Cattex, maybe a little stronger. Art Show balloons felt like they held up more.

          Comment

          • AlterPlatzer
            Senior Member
            • Jun 2024
            • 1528

            #20
            Here's my take on Decomex 18" or D18 for short. Bargain Balloons has the It's a Girl print balloons on sale, so I bought a few bags. My observation when it comes to Decomex stuffing balloons is that they tend to be as strong, if not stronger than Q18 stuffing balloons. The regular D18s are not as strong as Qualatex.

            Here we have a maximum inflated D18 stuffing balloon, a q16 (Jeweltone Lime) and a D18 stuffing balloon with fully inflated (lavender) Q16 inside of it:

            hwDdmjO.jpg

            D18 stuffers have wide necks, but they don't get very long and even with this much neck inflation, they're rather difficult to tie. The printing sorts of messes up the smoothness of the surface, but the bare latex is close to that buttery softness of a Q16.

            I like to hug and hump balloons and D18 stuffing balloons are pretty close to a Q24, but without the neck. Remember that stuffing balloons are made for stuffing things inside them, so the have to be stretchy and pliable. Since they're usually displayed neck-up, there's no need for them to have long necks, but they do need wide necks.

            Here's the max inflated D18 stuffer with a fully inflated D18 stuffer with a Tuf-Tex 17" Plum Purple inside.

            QtG8hM0.jpg

            Here's a D18 stuffer next to a regular D18. The regular D18s have much longer necks, but aren't near as wide and aren't as soft and pliable as the D18 stuffers.

            NCx0wQS.jpg

            IDK - I like D18 stuffers because they're a big, wide balloon, but not too big like a 36" and rather difficult to accidentally pop. I get it that they're plain looking, but you can add some color by inflating another balloon inside.

            Speaking of which, I have on several occasions had a Tuf-Tex 17" inside D18 stuffer and in the heat of bouncing on the double-balloon, I've had the inner balloon pop, but not the outer balloon.
            It's OK to love balloons.
            There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

            Comment

            • AlterPlatzer
              Senior Member
              • Jun 2024
              • 1528

              #21
              Not to hijack the thread, but what's the status on Art Show balloons. I haven't been able to get 12" Art Show balloons in over a year.

              They are (or were) in Dnipro. Customs records show they haven't shipped any product since May 2022.
              It's OK to love balloons.
              There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

              Comment

              • nonpop
                Soft balloons first
                • Jul 2024
                • 104

                #22
                I don't know what happened to Art show. But great work you've done on the comparisons above AlterPlatzer! A bit hard to interpret how this would affect the order of the list or det values for strength and stiffness. Could you share something on that?

                And the rest of you, did I scare you all with the homework term there? I don't believe that everyone agrees with the order and values already... 😁

                And there must be someone with experience on the brands without data.

                Comment

                • Guest

                  #23
                  Sempertex stuffing balloons are affectionately known as the baby Q24, so I guess the D18 is similar. They are ridiculously strong and were specifically designed for a better feel. Working with Q18 could be like trying to knot razor wire.

                  I know I mentioned Gemar 19" already but are Cattex 19" really so weak? They always seem to put up a good fight.

                  I have seen countless videos of people bouncing on overinflated and necked Kalisan 18", so they must be pretty strong. I think they were the subject of another thread recently.

                  BSA 17" blow up very tight, like rock hard, which is exciting for some people, but they are actually quite unpredictable and weak at max capacity. You can make them last a bit longer by prestretching the neck. I think someone else mentioned that in another thread a while ago.

                  As for the homework, humans don't usually agree with themselves, let alone each other.

                  Comment

                  • nonpop
                    Soft balloons first
                    • Jul 2024
                    • 104

                    #24
                    Is there anyone out there with experience with these balloon brands who can rank them among the other brands in the list above? I haven't tried any of them myself, and I would be very grateful if someone could help me avoid a bad purchase:

                    How stiff are Gummiwerk Czermak & Feger, and Kalisan compared to for example Qualatex?

                    Something like a "Gummiwerk Czermak & Feger is typically between Qualatex and Belbal in terms of stiffness" - Great! I'm looking for softer balloons so then I won't buy those. Or a "Kalisan is softer than Qualatex, so probably a 4 or 5 on the stiffness scale.

                    Comment

                    • Guest

                      #25
                      I have experience of all the brands I mentioned but I think you have just proven that that won't be enough. One thing I have noticed about this forum is that there is always some reason why people are afraid to try something new. Lots of questions are asked but the answers provided are never satisfactory for one reason or another. People want cast iron guarantees that if they follow the steps then they will have a certain experience or outcome.

                      Most of the good things in life are found through experimentation. If you think that is bad, can you imagine what the process of discovering what things are safe to eat must have been like without medicine or electronic communication? Of course, this is only one example.

                      Comment

                      • nonpop
                        Soft balloons first
                        • Jul 2024
                        • 104

                        #26
                        Am I really proving anything? And I'm not asking for rock solid answers or scientific accuracy. I just want someone to compare some balloons with others. You are right that I've gotten several replies, and I'm very happy about it!

                        What is frustrating though, is that a lot of the feedback I've gotten is in the direction of "this balloon is soft" or "this balloon is very strong". But defining a strength number based on that is mostly guesswork, from me that haven't even tested the balloon... What I want opinions on (and yes it is opinions) is how one balloon are compared to some of the brands that are already in the table with some values.

                        And I'm really curious, why can it be that people don't provide that..?

                        Comment

                        • LoonPopper
                          Senior Member
                          • Aug 2011
                          • 772

                          #27
                          Originally posted by nonpop
                          Am I really proving anything? And I'm not asking for rock solid answers or scientific accuracy. I just want someone to compare some balloons with others. You are right that I've gotten several replies, and I'm very happy about it!

                          What is frustrating though, is that a lot of the feedback I've gotten is in the direction of "this balloon is soft" or "this balloon is very strong". But defining a strength number based on that is mostly guesswork, from me that haven't even tested the balloon... What I want opinions on (and yes it is opinions) is how one balloon are compared to some of the brands that are already in the table with some values.

                          And I'm really curious, why can it be that people don't provide that..?
                          Maybe because we're all different and have a different opinion then others, some don't mind rock hard balloons and others like them soft, if I say Qualatex is more of a 8/8 instead of the 6/6 then am I wrong since it was rated 6/6 or Tuf-tex would be a 6/8 it's up to each individual preferences what they assume the strength and stiffness is, and then there are poppers especially that just go it's a balloon and all this don't matter as long as they can make it go bang and I would put myself in that category, I don't care as long as the balloon is inflated, played with for a bit and meets it end with a nice big bang and give me an arousal from the bangs.
                          Blow, Baby, Blow...when will it pop nobody knows!

                          Comment

                          • NEKOCC
                            Member
                            • Mar 2020
                            • 81

                            #28
                            I have bought a pack of 12 inch Fengche and Sempertex, same color, due to I have noticed they have some similar color (all information below just for pastel dusk color, 12inch) .

                            For the un-inflated balloons, touch feeling of Sempertex is better than Fengche.

                            When inflating the balloon to its rated size, these 2 brand have similar stiffness , Fengche is a bit softer. But please note Sempertex pastel dusk color is also softer than Sempertex standard color.

                            When I try to over inflate them, Sempertex is the same as before, very hard to neck, or I should say, no neck. Fengche like the common balloons, have a short neck. The situation of stiffness is same as rated size.

                            At last, Sempertex is bigger than Fengche when blow to burst.

                            According to your score list, I think Fengche can have Strength - 5, Stiffness- 5 or 6. But please note even for balloons of the same brand, different colors can have slight differences in the result of Strength and Stiffness.

                            By the way, I think Strength score of Unique/Global payaso and Qualatex is low, Unique/Global payaso is thin, but the strength is beyond my expectation, can have 5 or 6. I always like ride Qualatex 16, because it can hold me for a very long time before pop, the strength score can be 7+
                            ​
                            Last edited by NEKOCC; 22-10-2024, 16:15.

                            Comment

                            • AJK64
                              Moderator
                              • Jun 2018
                              • 1280

                              #29
                              "Creative" brand
                              Specifically 12 inch soap crystals

                              Strength = 7
                              Stiffness = 2

                              Notes.
                              I love these balloons. They very easily get bigger than 12 inches. Have amazing necks and can take a lot of a beating before bursting. They are super soft and squash even when maxed out.

                              Comment

                              • PomeranianLooner
                                Senior Member
                                • Feb 2016
                                • 102

                                #30
                                Originally posted by AlterPlatzer
                                From my experiences with Belbal 14" is they are very difficult to B2P because they inflate all the way to the nozzle like Q16s.

                                Although some off the most painful snaps I've ever gotten from sit popping balloons came from Belbal 14" where Q16s rarely cause painful snaps.
                                BB14 is the first balloon I intentionally blown past its limits. You just need to hold the neck and press ring to your lips. 😎

                                Comment

                                Working...