Our official scale of balloon brands and types

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • nonpop
    Soft balloons first
    • Jul 2024
    • 104

    Our official scale of balloon brands and types

    We've all spent our time doing research and buying balloons from brands for testing.
    Let's help other looners out there so we generally avoid buying balloons we don't like.

    We're building this data as a community. To help other future looners to easily find their favorites earlier in life

    The comparison table - Work in progress
    Brand Strength Stiffness Comment Brand site
    Sempertex 9 7
    Balloonia 9 4
    Belbal 8 8
    Tuftex 8 4
    Amscan 7 7
    BWS / Rifco 6 5
    Art Show 7 5
    Qualatex 6 6
    Fengche 5 5
    Decomex 5 5 18" stuffing (Wide neck) especially strong. Not as strong as Qualatex? https://www.decomexballoon.com/
    Cattex 5 6
    Creative 7 2 Specifically 12 inch soap crystals
    Gemar 5 8 19" are specially strong. https://gemar.it/
    Kalisan 6? 4?
    Unique/Globos Payaso 4 3
    Pop 3 2 Bought at Dollarstore. Thin punchball.
    The parameters
    First, let's discuss all the parameters. And there are so many that we could bring in. And in this first comparison database we're talking about latex balloons (not mylar or inflatables).

    The list is long of details where we all have opinons. But Let's start with softness and strenght for two reasons:
    1. These are things that are very difficult to see from photos or even when you stand in a store with the package in your hands
    2. It is relevant for all that loves latex balloons, both poppers and non-poppers.

    The list is still work in progress, so feel free to chime in any time šŸ˜
    What do you think? Please give your thoughts.
    Last edited by nonpop; 26-03-2025, 12:15.
  • nonpop
    Soft balloons first
    • Jul 2024
    • 104

    #2
    I see a few thumbs up and some readers, so I guess I’ll kick things off. As a non-popper, I don’t have much knowledge about the strength of the most solid brands, so I’ll leave those recommendations to the rest of you! It would be great if we could start a small comparison here as a foundation, and later I’ll set up a survey to get some community input and a bit of democracy to it all.

    Parameter Definitions
    We’ll use a scale of 1 to 10 for each of the following categories

    Strength
    How much can the balloon handle in terms of pressure/air, squeezing, or sitting?
    • 1: Very weak—this balloon feels old, damaged, or too fragile to even reach its intended size.
    • 9: The strongest balloon you’ve encountered so far! Let’s keep a buffer here for future discoveries if the vendor releases something even stronger.
    • 10: Super strong. We’ll reserve this for anything exceptional that we might find together over time.

    We’ll probably need someone with more experience to define the upper limit of what we’d still classify as a balloon, but this is beyond my expertise, so I’d appreciate help on this one.


    Stiffness (or softness)
    How soft is the balloon when it’s not fully inflated?
    • 1: Extremely soft—this balloon requires almost no effort to blow up. It doesn’t return to its original size when deflated, and a ā€œ1ā€ should be softer than an inflated condom.
    • 10: Very firm—it takes a lot of effort to start inflating, and even at 30% of its size, it gives significant resistance when squeezed.

    Note that softness often correlates with strength. It’s hard to have a balloon that’s both the strongest and the softest at the same time, but there will be differenses, and that's what we'll find out together.

    Come on! Bring your evaluation for each of your brands šŸ˜€
    Last edited by nonpop; 26-03-2025, 12:10.

    Comment

    • nonpop
      Soft balloons first
      • Jul 2024
      • 104

      #3
      So let me start with my short list then:
      Brand Strength Softness
      Unique/Globos Payaso 5 4
      Qualatex 7 6
      Belbal 8 8
      Cattex 6 5
      For me in prioritized order when considering balloons:
      1. How soft the balloon is when not fully inflated. (As a non-popper I love the tactile feeling and how it folds around me. Unique/Globos Payaso is typically one of my favorites)
      2. The strength (and as a non-popper this is ofc difficult to combine with the above)
      3. Great shapes like long big ones, hearts, mickey and so on

      Thoughts? I'm sure you all have opinions. There is a lot of other brands out there, and please give them, with your review on the scales.
      Last edited by nonpop; 17-10-2024, 08:39.

      Comment

      • Scooter
        é¢Øčˆ¹å¤©ę‰
        • May 2022
        • 497

        #4
        I've tried out a good number of brands, but haven't really "tested" any of them too hard, so take this with a grain of salt.
        Brand Strength Stiffness
        Belbal 8 8
        Qualatex 6 6
        Sempertex 9 7
        Tuftex 8 4
        Cattex 5 6
        Unique/GP 4 3
        Art Show 7 5
        Gemar 5 8
        Balloonia 9 4

        Comment

        • nonpop
          Soft balloons first
          • Jul 2024
          • 104

          #5
          Nice, thanks! Keep it going everyone. And Scooter I noticed you switched to the term stiffness there. Better! Because the more stiffness, the higher number. I actually thought about using softness where high number where more soft, for the same reason. But the numbers wouldn't follow corrolation between strength and softness so I switched. Will update my post also, accordingly.

          Comment

          • Guest

            #6
            This has been tried a few times. I think the main issues are that it becomes quite difficult to follow after a lot of replies, and also it needs to be kept up-to-date somehow.

            Are all varieties of balloons from the same manufacturer the same? I would have thought not, for various reasons, without even considering things like stuffing balloons and shapes. People often report significant variation between colors too.

            Gemar 19" are crazy strong in my experience. The Gemar 19" was always a bit confusing because it seems so small and inflates so tightly in the beginning, as if it won't make it to rated size. The new ones seem slightly bigger.

            Another thing that occurred to me is that the weight of a balloon can be useful for estimating quality/strength.

            Comment

            • nonpop
              Soft balloons first
              • Jul 2024
              • 104

              #7
              Great! And thanks for the feedback!

              My job will be to gather and facilitate. Og something is already started the job will be easier. Can you guide me in the right direction? Should be some old threads then I suppose. Would be great with some kind to them, of you have šŸ‘

              Comment

              • AlterPlatzer
                Senior Member
                • Jun 2024
                • 1528

                #8
                From my experiences with Belbal 14" is they are very difficult to B2P because they inflate all the way to the nozzle like Q16s.

                Although some off the most painful snaps I've ever gotten from sit popping balloons came from Belbal 14" where Q16s rarely cause painful snaps.
                It's OK to love balloons.
                There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

                Comment

                • Guest

                  #9
                  Originally posted by nonpop
                  Great! And thanks for the feedback!

                  My job will be to gather and facilitate. Og something is already started the job will be easier. Can you guide me in the right direction? Should be some old threads then I suppose. Would be great with some kind to them, of you have šŸ‘
                  Here are a few. Probably the first link is the closest to what you are trying to do.





                  Is there a summary of what different balloons are like someplace? if this has been asked and I failed to find it please point me to it. I’m looking to know what brands/sizes are most consistent and reliable. Like no “church windows” or few (none) unexpected pops, always reach the same size. Is the latex soft or firm (hard?)


                  Hi all, phobic of popping here.. just started to buy good quality loons. Was wondering what everyone's favourite balloon is and most reliable with no defects and pops would be? Just placed a Belbal order so keen to see these. Cheers




                  Edit: There's also an old wiki here: https://balloons.fandom.com/wiki/Balloons_Wiki

                  Another edit: https://balloune-qc.com/ has some information about balloon weights, if I remember rightly.

                  Comment

                  • Aly
                    Junior Member
                    • Feb 2023
                    • 12

                    #10

                    Qualatex is soft. Sempertex is firm followed by gemar. Gemar is the thickest and can go way past their rated size. That is with testing with normal 12 inch balloons. There is some differences with firmness though with size like 12, 18 , 24 or 36 inches. Balloon types also affect it like regular, pastel, metalic, soap or crystal, decorator types and transparent. Shapes like heart, figure balloons, round, oval and long (360).

                    Comment

                    • nonpop
                      Soft balloons first
                      • Jul 2024
                      • 104

                      #11
                      Originally posted by darcynader
                      Here are a few. Probably the first link is the closest to what you are trying to do.
                      Nice! Thank you so much šŸ˜
                      I'll go through them. And if it covers and seems solid I'm not saying we should do it all over. Just by my own experience it's been difficult to find this info and I want others to find it more easily than I did. I'll try to structure it and summarize.

                      Thank you too, Aly! I'll add these to an overview. And yes, there are knowledge about sizes, shapes and colors/finish that affect it also, but let's see if we can include more of that later in the process.

                      Comment

                      • AlterPlatzer
                        Senior Member
                        • Jun 2024
                        • 1528

                        #12
                        I'm finding that Decomex 18" stuffing balloons are pretty good. They're very difficult to pop and are nearly as soft as Q16s.

                        Decomex 18" decorator balloons don't even compare to their stuffing balloons. Not sure why that is.
                        It's OK to love balloons.
                        There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

                        Comment

                        • nonpop
                          Soft balloons first
                          • Jul 2024
                          • 104

                          #13
                          Originally posted by AlterPlatzer
                          I'm finding that Decomex 18" stuffing balloons are pretty good. They're very difficult to pop and are nearly as soft as Q16s.

                          Decomex 18" decorator balloons don't even compare to their stuffing balloons. Not sure why that is.
                          Thank you for great input. I agree about the strength of the stuffing balloons. I guess they're made thicker to hold the stuff you add on the inside without popping. And that costs more I guess. And that's valid reason to have a separate row for each vendor that sells stuffing balloons in the comparison. Do you want to add numbers to strength and stiffness for these balloons and compare that to Qualatex (and other brands?) so I see how you understand the numbers and compare them.

                          Comment

                          • AlterPlatzer
                            Senior Member
                            • Jun 2024
                            • 1528

                            #14
                            Originally posted by nonpop

                            Thank you for great input. I agree about the strength of the stuffing balloons. I guess they're made thicker to hold the stuff you add on the inside without popping. And that costs more I guess. And that's valid reason to have a separate row for each vendor that sells stuffing balloons in the comparison. Do you want to add numbers to strength and stiffness for these balloons and compare that to Qualatex (and other brands?) so I see how you understand the numbers and compare them.
                            Something that I don't understand about stuffing balloons is the pricing. Plain (clear, no printing) Qualatex stuffing balloons cost much less than printed stuffing balloons. Decomex stuffing balloons cost the same, with or without printing.

                            It's near the end of my balloon season*, but I'll try to get out to do some serious comparisons this weekend and possibly deliver some data.

                            *By balloon season I mean that most of my serious activities with balloons take place at my dacha which is neither heated nor air conditioned. In the summer it is often too hot and in the winter it is too cold.

                            I do have a forced-air heater that sort of works, but it's hard to regulate, doesn't heat the space very well and I have to carry the fuel in with 20 liter buckets. It's easier to just put the balloons away until until spring.

                            I always have balloons inflated at home, but in the off-season, my balloon fun is largely limited to a few smaller balloons. I have teenagers at home and can't get too carried away. Living in this faraway place has its advantages, but also disadvantages. Sometimes late at night, I think I hear Baba Yaga screaming.
                            Last edited by AlterPlatzer; 16-10-2024, 03:05.
                            It's OK to love balloons.
                            There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

                            Comment

                            • nonpop
                              Soft balloons first
                              • Jul 2024
                              • 104

                              #15
                              Thank you! Hehe, balloon season 😁 That's a new term to me. But this is the forum to talk about it, and I understand your term šŸ™Œ
                              Looking forward to getting your input and data.

                              I'm starting to think that we should have a column for comments as a text field next to every vendor in our list. I've gone through some of the links above that we got from Guest. There is a lot of good data. Some of it is very detailed though, and might be too ambitious for this stage. I'd like us to build a list of ~90% of the most used/favorited balloon brands among us with those two parameters and then expand with more data if wanted. But it is very easy to over complicate things with colors shapes and minimal variations that for sure will be overwhelming to maintain. Hence a comment column where we could add smaller details or expecptions, that means a lot to some of us. For example a "18" stuffing balloons are specially strong, but still soft like a Q16" for a Decomex comment.

                              Comment

                              Working...