A few material science questions re: inflation

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Thinskinned
    Look Out!
    • Jul 2024
    • 247

    A few material science questions re: inflation

    So I'm a semi-popper, but something that's been a bit of a hangup in general is worrying about balloons popping while inflating due to defects/weakening from previous inflations. I believe this to be related to anxiety, so there's a possibility my concerns are irrational. I'm more comfortable inflating with a fast pump because it's really fast and I don't have time to think before the balloon is starting to neck out a bit, but I'd like to be more comfortable (or, if not, at least knowledgeable) blowing them up by mouth as well -- I enjoy that so much more.

    I have no issues blowing up just about any balloon nearly to rated size, but I start to get scared before the neck even comes out a little. I know that there's a lot more room in the balloon because the pump will go right past that point quick as you like, but I'm worried about defects causing the balloon to pop prematurely right next to my face.

    Of note: I'm just using retail balloons, none of the purpose-made looner balloons -- I assume the large cattexes etc have great QC and there's less to worry about?

    With that said, a few series of Material Science/Physics questions that I hope you all will have the answers for:


    1) What are the most common defects? How common are they? When will they cause a balloon to catastrophically fail -- during inflation, overinflation, or handling/riding/bouncing?

    2 ) I had a few crystal 11" uniques, one had what looked like a round "clear" spot on a colored balloon right where the drip point should have been, is lack of color fine, or was the latex thinner there? it was already a little overinflated and tied off before I noticed it, so even if it is a defect is it something to be concerned about?

    3) Another of the uniques, I guess it was burgundy? Right when you start to inflate there's these white lines crisscrossing the surface of the balloon. is that just talc or is there something that happens to latex that causes it to do that? if so, is it bad?

    4) does inflating the same balloon over and over make it more likely to pop during inflation? I know about hysteresis and that the balloon will get bigger and bigger on subsequent inflations, but does that make it weaker while being inflated? how long can they be reused for? will defects that did not cause the balloon to pop on first inflation cause pops on re-inflations?

    5) if a balloon is already used and stretched out, is it necessary to stretch it by hand prior to re-inflation? I always do and I think I tore a hole in one of my TT17s doing that, so maybe it's not necessary/actually a bad idea?

    6) Am I being irrational? Are balloons popping during inflation something to be concerned about in 2024? (sorry, this isn't really a material science question)
  • Kitten
    Senior Member
    • Jul 2023
    • 548

    #2
    I can answer a couple. The clear weakspots seem to be fine. I've had loads of them and the balloons still get really big.

    Blowing up and letting the air out over and over will eventually make it pop. I've done that for fun. It's usually pretty big when it pops though.

    The most common defect that pops it before it's full is a small pin hole. They're pretty easily seen.

    Comment

    • Thinskinned
      Look Out!
      • Jul 2024
      • 247

      #3
      Thanks! So "pinholes" are actually small holes that you can see, and feel/hear air coming out of?

      Comment

      • srob2
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2017
        • 552

        #4
        1) Balloons are not manufactured to exact tolerance, this varies, uniques are much more variable and Qualatex are very consistent. I think manufactures assume that balloons will be inflated only to rated size, or by people intending the balloon to pop or at least okay with it popping. To me, if a balloon reached rate size, it isn't defective, even if it has weak spots or other reasons it won't get as big. If I have a pack of 9 inch balloons, and half get as big as they are going to, and won't pop without a few blows, are the rest defective if they get to 9 inches if they pop before they neck or before I have to really blow hard? If you count these irregularities as defects, defects are common with most balloons having some. If not, defects are rare. Something that makes a balloon pop before rate size is usually obvious - a tiny hole that lets out air, material stuck together, a balloon that inflates with a large bulge on one side. Occasionally what looks like a good balloon will exploded for no apparent reason before it is rate size, but this is very rare.

        2) If you are intentionally doing a b2p, this is not something to be concerned about, the balloon will probably get just as big. Latex is thicker at the dip point, so popping here is rare. Balloons that were already overinflated once almost always get bigger.

        3) I'd worry more about the texture of the latex than inconsistent color.

        4) I am surprised at this question. I thought every little kid blew up a balloon multiple times until it exploded in their face. I must have done it 2 dozen times growing up before intentionally popping anything. Blowing up a balloon, especially overinflating it, stretches the latex. This means it will be weaker and hold less pressure, although it takes less pressure to make it the same size. This usually means balloons inflated a 2nd time will pop much bigger than balloons only inflated once. A b2p on 3rd inflation will get bigger than a 2nd, but not by as much. If you keep going, eventually the balloon will pop before it gets as big as it did last time. Even blowing a balloon to rate size repeatedly will eventually pop it. Defects don't have much to do with this, as overinflating a balloon once means it isn't going to pop due to defects.

        5) I would not stretch a balloon that has already been inflated once. I don't think stretching does much, especially if you aren't intending to b2p on first inflation.

        6) I don't understand the question. If you want to avoid balloons popping during inflation, or want to make them pop during inflation, it is a concern, but no more than in 2023 or 1998. I do think it is more difficult to pop balloons (on purpose or by accident) than it used to be 20 years ago, but this varies more by brand. If you are concerned about your health, I am not an expert, but the risk seems low. B2ps, while having a high decibel measurement, are impulse sound and not dangerous from your hearing as constant sound like standing next to a jet engine. Shrapnel to the face can be unpleasant, and has really turned me off b2ps at times, but permanent damage is rare. Almost always, especially if the balloon necked, pieces fly opposite your face.

        Comment

        • Thinskinned
          Look Out!
          • Jul 2024
          • 247

          #5
          Thanks very much for your reply -- I am not concerned about my physical health, but I am an anxiety sufferer and have a predisposition to blow potential risk factors and/or certain outcomes way out of proportion.

          Fwiw, i am a semi-popper but i am also phobic to an extent, i only really can pop in very controlled situations -- I'd like to change that and the best way for my mind to be okay with it is to ask questions. I apologize if some of the questions don't really make sense.

          Comment

          • b0f0s0f
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2016
            • 329

            #6
            I wish I had the time and equipment to run some of these stress/degradation experiments, I have wondered the same thing for quite some time. It seems to me that in order of importance the degrading factors are oil, moisture, and cycles, in that order. The small amount of oil on your hands degrades the latex, and I suspect the moisture of your breath does to a lesser extent as well. The cycling of inflation and deflation most likely accelerates this degradation as the molecules are put under load, allowing the oil/moisture to work down into the material. This is probably the primary reason for the common experience of blowing up a balloon repeatedly and it popping spontaneously even if it was never inflated to a very large size.

            The interesting and unknown part is how much of a limit the material itself provides in ideal circumstances. Is there a finite number of cycles the balloon can tolerate, even under pristine conditions? Does the rate of stress application in the material matter? Temperature? Maximum strain (elongation)? etc. I wouldn't have thought much about this aspect except once I cut a balloon into pieces and stretched a strip of it between my fingers and found that it failed after only a handful of stretches. It tended to fail near where I held it so it was probably accelerated by the oil on my hands, and I was stretching it rapidly which is probably more likely to cause internal damage to the material, but I suspect there is also an upper limit on how many inflations it can go through. We need some experimental data on this.

            In the meantime though just wash your hands before handling balloons and don't keep them around for too long (if you keep inflating it again and again it'll fail eventually). But a new balloon that makes it to rated size is almost guaranteed to not pop until it reaches its maximum limits, especially on the 2nd inflation. I haven't tested this since I'm too scared to attempt a b2p myself but in videos I rarely see pops occur before the balloon is completely stretched all over its surface.

            Comment

            • srob2
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2017
              • 552

              #7
              Depending on what you do your hands, oil probably has very little to do with it. I grab a balloon out of a bag and put it in my mouth, I am usually touching the neck, not the bulb portion. If I b2p a fresh balloon, it will almost always neck before it pops, but if I am repeatedly inflating it many times, it almost always pops before it necks, so the part that broke had no oil on it.

              I suspect there is a finite amount the latex can stretch. A near b2p is going to stretch the balloon a lot more, and a lot more evenly, than blowing it smaller than rated size. Blow a balloon to rate size 10 times and then keep blowing and it will almost certainly pop before it necks. Blow up a similar balloon until the neck is completely full and repeat and the balloon almost certainly won't make it to a 10th inflation.

              Temperature and inflation rate do make a difference. Slower blowing and warmer balloons get bigger.

              Any balloon is guaranteed to not pop until it reaches its maximum limits, that's the only way to know the maximum limits.

              Comment

              • Asclepio
                Senior Member
                • Sep 2018
                • 539

                #8
                Unless you are using a looner designed balloon, any other companies that makes “mainstream” balloons won’t think even once on subsequent inflations for the design of their loons. Of course there will be capabilities of many subsequent inflations but nothing intentional, maybe 100% related to quality of the latex. And talking about overinflation…. I’m sure there is no company that test their loons at overinflation sizes, they just don’t care about it, the balloon is marked as 17” and it reached 17”? Well that’s a success and the job is done ✅
                Your balloon is marked as 17” and it can go as big as 20”? Probably the company doesn’t care and doesn’t even know about it. So after rated size and after first inflation….. you are by your own, there is not balloon company that thinks that you will blow it more that one time.
                A looner looking for fun, against violence or people with hightened moral idealism…. I just care about loons, so don’t ruin the fun.

                Comment

                Working...