Why 16" are the loudest?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Javirod
    Member
    • Aug 2022
    • 78

    Why 16" are the loudest?

    I've read in some posts that 14", 16" (or even 18") are louder than 24"s. If it's true, I don't understand why, the hugest balloon liberates more energy, so shouldn't it sound louder?
  • Dust of the Saturn
    Stretched like space-time
    • Feb 2018
    • 411

    #2
    Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

    size and volume don't matter, pressure and tightness do.
    Stretched like space-time

    Comment

    • Javirod
      Member
      • Aug 2022
      • 78

      #3
      Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

      Then 12" should be the loudest... Or even 5" ones

      Comment

      • Dust of the Saturn
        Stretched like space-time
        • Feb 2018
        • 411

        #4
        Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

        well, they kinda are. 12 inch balloons can get really loud. I don't know about the 5 inchers though.

        There's also a hidden variable that has to do with the durability of the latex. how much pressure can it hold before it bursts. The larger the balloon, the larger the possiblity of a premature pop due to a weakpoint or point of failure. Which is why I think larger balloons tend to pop in larger chunks rather than shred. Probably due to them failing somewhere before reaching their maximum capacity.

        Also, smaller balloons pop in a higher frequency, or give off a sharper bang. I don't know if this is due to the latex snapping or the volume of air, but it's something I've observed too.

        Taking all variables and everything else into account, sizes between 11 to 24 inches have the best chances to be the loudest. I'm no expert though and I never had the opportunity to experience anything larger than 12 inch. Blown2Bits maybe can help.
        Last edited by Dust of the Saturn; 07-01-2023, 23:32.
        Stretched like space-time

        Comment

        • Javirod
          Member
          • Aug 2022
          • 78

          #5
          Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

          Cool, makes sense...thanks for your answer!

          Comment

          • LoonerHoax
            Senior Member
            • May 2020
            • 521

            #6
            Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

            The frequency of the sound when they pop varies based on size as well. Larger balloons have a deeper boom while smaller balloons are more of a higher pitched crack. I think the volume of air has something to do with it. Probably the speed in which the air moves once it is released. I never delved deeply into the physics of sound waves. I learned enough to tune rooms and make sure mics didn't feedback as an audio engineer...

            Comment

            • srob2
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2017
              • 552

              #7
              Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

              b2p a 5 inch and its really loud, although it can be a lot harder than a 9 inch. A lot depends on the strength and thickness of the latex. Cheap 5" balloons are thin and weak and not as strong as larger balloons.

              Comment

              • Seidenki
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2016
                • 202

                #8
                Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

                There are so many variables for the loudness of the pop, including how much of the pressure wave interacts with the sound waves.

                TT 24" are, to me, "louder" than TT 17"s, but a lot of that is because of the much stronger pressure wave. The impulse of the latex failing feels about the same, but I felt the pressure wave and my ears were ringing longer when the 24s go if I'm in the same room.

                Comment

                • Whale Rider
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2022
                  • 531

                  #9
                  Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

                  Originally posted by Seidenki
                  There are so many variables for the loudness of the pop, including how much of the pressure wave interacts with the sound waves.

                  TT 24" are, to me, "louder" than TT 17"s, but a lot of that is because of the much stronger pressure wave. The impulse of the latex failing feels about the same, but I felt the pressure wave and my ears were ringing longer when the 24s go if I'm in the same room.
                  The main "thing" that generates the pop is the tensile strength in the streched balloon skin, its where the energy is stored and that sudden release of energy is the source of the pop. The "storage" can be different you can make that skin thicker or have more interlinks between the molecules, different/more inert filler material and so on. All of these things have some effect of the pop sound frequency and amplitude.

                  Comment

                  • Whale Rider
                    Senior Member
                    • Nov 2022
                    • 531

                    #10
                    Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

                    beautiful pic... yes you get more than one pressure wave since you have several contributing factors the relaxation speed of these contriibuting factors is different so the sound/pressure wave is generated at different times, .. and the more or less high overpressure in the loon that I forgot. Am surprised you can get as high as 30 mbarg in a loon... fantastic pic...

                    Comment

                    • Whale Rider
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2022
                      • 531

                      #11
                      Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

                      Originally posted by Blown2Bits
                      Yes, it clearly shows that a shockwave already left the balloon before the latex had time to snap back together. So while the snapping latex makes a loud sound, i am not sure if it is the source of the loud bang.
                      you have several sources even the latex sheet will make more than one sounde since the relaxation wont be from one to zebro some of it will be transfered into kinetic energy the shreds are flying around and will hit something. this pic does not show the amplitude of the sound wave only changes in the density of the medium but not how much the density changes... it also shows interference of different pressure (sound) wave generating mechanisms.

                      I doubt that 30 mbarg generate a really meaningful bang but that will be the first sound wave I agree, the secondary waves will be generated by the latex sheet since that needs time to contract (not much but still a time difference) while the overpressure starts expanding instantly.

                      that pic is really marvelous ^^

                      Comment

                      • Whale Rider
                        Senior Member
                        • Nov 2022
                        • 531

                        #12
                        Re: Why 16" are the loudest?

                        Originally posted by Blown2Bits
                        If you pop anything else by adding pressure, like plastic bags, you also get a big bang. And plastic bags will not contract again. So I am not convinced that the latex contracting is the biggest contribution to the bang.
                        I have not had a bang for these... but have rarely a heard a bag pop... the largest energy storage in a loon is the internal pressure 30 mbarg aint much but thats even higher than I anticipated but I trust you on that number, and the streched latex sheet both are roughly in equilibrium (Gleichgewicht) you can also generate kinda loud nouses by just streching a large sheet of latex and release it suddenly... just dont be near, that can be painful with TERA bands for example... there are no other energy storages unless I am overlooking something but I dont see anything else...

                        Comment

                        Working...