What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • lonelylooner
    Member
    • Jan 2012
    • 55

    What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

    I'm a semi popper into bouncing and riding. Of course you won't be able to engage in this sort of looner fun without the occasional accidental pop.

    Something I have somewhat noticed...I've had huge 16" and larger loons pop with a dull thud before while smaller loons (around 12") have gone off like gunshots!

    Makes me wonder why? What factors contribute towards how loud balloons pop?
  • LondonLarry
    Could be a chat bot
    • Jul 2019
    • 627

    #2
    Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

    Thickness of latex, tightness of balloon that sort of thing.

    Comment

    • balloonPatcher
      Senior Member
      • Jun 2020
      • 291

      #3
      Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

      Could it be the air pressure differential between the inside of the balloon and the room air?

      Comment

      • Seidenki
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2016
        • 202

        #4
        Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

        Originally posted by balloonPatcher
        Could it be the air pressure differential between the inside of the balloon and the room air?
        Yes. The thicker the latex and the tighter the balloon the higher the pressure differential, I would imagine.

        Comment

        • Guest

          #5
          Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

          Ooh, physics! I loooove physics!
          Most think the "pop" sound that comes from the balloon bursting is the sound of the high pressure air escaping back to equilibrium with the ambient pressure but this is a common misconception. The "pop" is actually the high tension & energy of the latex returning back to it's relaxed state. It is an actual supersonic boom, believe it or not! Depending on the thickness and tension of the latex determines the loudness of the boom.

          Cheers!

          Comment

          • Guest

            #6
            Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

            Exactly like the crack of a whip i might add

            Cheers!

            Comment

            • srob2
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2017
              • 552

              #7
              Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

              The room makes a bigger difference than the balloon. I'd love to hear a b2p in an Anechoic Chamber - there are a few balloon pop videos online but nothing that big or loud. A room with hard surfaces will always be louder.

              Comment

              • Common Loon
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2020
                • 232

                #8
                Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                I love this conversation because everyone has one piece of the puzzle and they all make the picture when you put them together I'm in the mood to write a bunch about this tonight.

                First is @srob2's point: the environment makes the first BIG difference. "When a balloon pops, you're really hearing the acoustics of the space itself," says one of the acousticians who used balloon pop sounds to recreate the echoes of the Hagia Sophia cathedral ( https://www.npr.org/2020/02/22/80840...-500-years-ago ). That's because balloon pops are some of the closest things to true impulse noise -- originating almost from a point source, with high intensity, narrow frequency band, and duration on the order of milliseconds. (Their technical writeup has more detail showing that this isn't exactly true but they were able to use spectral analysis to make adjustments to compensate for the small amount of non-impulse-ness in the pops, https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/693439 .)

                My phobia prevented me from intentionally popping balloons until I was about 25 years old... and when I finally decided to try, I found that doing it outdoors was way easier than I thought it would be. I remember I had been at a party in a grassy, breezy outdoor park, and when someone was cleaning up and popping the party balloons, they barely sounded like handclaps from just a few feet away. Impulse noise is easier to absorb by soft surfaces, easier to blow away when the air isn't still, and also very easy to reflect on reflective surfaces... so these all make a huge impact on your perception of the sound.

                So, now take this out of the equation. In the same room, what could make one pop louder than another? Three effects: shape, size, and pressure. But they are all inter-related.

                Like @QBubbleBalloon says, one source of noise is the (very) sudden release of tension forces from the latex skin. Higher tension - due to thicker/stiffer latex and tighter inflation - means more force to release. But also, those forces don't generate much sonic power if they're released too slowly. The quicker the forces are released, the more powerful the noise.

                Think of it this way: if you and a friend are pulling hard on opposite ends of a fabric sheet and it suddenly rips apart, it'll make a nice "FWWIP" sound. But if there's a small tear or a zipper in the fabric and it comes apart more slowly, even though you're pulling with the same forces, there's not nearly as much noise power. To get the loudest noise, you need the most force to be released over the least amount of time.

                This is where shape comes into the equation. A balloon that pops along one or two long crack surfaces -- the latex breaks into only a couple large pieces -- means that the forces took longer to dissipate. (They had to wait for the crack to go all the way around the balloon before the skin could fully retract.) This is like the zipper in the fabric, or a pane of glass that is slowly bent until it cracks in two. But a balloon that pops into tiny shreds, does that because one crack surface isn't enough to dissipate the amount of force in the latex, so it splits into two, and these split into four, eight, sixteen, etc. This is like a pane of glass being dropped on the floor and shattering, and the forces are dissipated over a shorter period of time.

                One way to encourage this shredding is to just increase force by making the balloon's inner pressure higher. For a given balloon, this means adding more air, of course... especially when the balloon is past full inflation (while it is still stretching, the internal pressure remains mostly constant). But, as we all know, different balloons have different qualities that affect pressure as well.

                One effect is, as mentioned, the thickness of the latex. Balloons with thinner walls, like Unique brand, exert less force on the air inside them at a given size than balloons with thicker walls, like Tuftex. This is also why some balloons feel softer and squishier than others, even beyond their full size.

                But the (rated) size of the balloon is also a major factor. Thicknesses being equal, the pressure inside a balloon is inversely proportional to the balloon's mean curvature - the average of the radii of the largest and smallest circles you could make by stretching two rubber bands around the balloon that crisscross at any given point. TL;DR, a spherical balloon half the size will have twice the internal pressure (for example, a 5" round would have twice the pressure of a 10" round if their latexes were stretched to the same thickness). But also, round shapes have the highest mean curvature for a given surface area: if you have a certain amount of latex to make a balloon with, making a round balloon instead of, say, an airship, will give you a balloon capable of the highest internal pressure.

                Also, and relatedly, in an inflated round balloon (ignoring the neck for the moment) the forces in the latex are isotropic - they're pulling roughly equally hard in every direction... again, a curvature effect. In a zeppelin or airship like a 260, the forces pulling sideways along the narrow width of the balloon are much stronger than the forces pulling longways along the length. So when an airship is punctured, the stronger forces win and the latex splits perpendicular to them. The crack runs up-and-down the length of the balloon and it opens up like a zipper usually in one big piece. But when a round balloon is punctured at high tension there's an immediate competition for crack directions and several cracks often form and begin to exponentially split into shreds. This, again, releases the forces in the least amount of time and creates a more powerful noise.

                OK, rounder, thicker, smaller, and tighter balloons would seem to make the most noise. So why don't looners like B2Ping 5" Qualatex rounds best? (Besides the fact that it's pretty hard to do with lung power and doesn't really build much suspense along the way?)

                The last element is frequency, the "pitch" of the impulse noise generated by the energy released. Because a smaller balloon has higher tension, it's like a thin guitar string stretched very tautly - when plucked, it makes a high-pitched sound. Bigger balloons generate lower-pitched sounds by contrast. That difference affects both the physiological and subjective ways that we experience the noise.

                Subjectively, you might notice that if you B2P a 5" round balloon the sound is high, harsh, and intense crack, like a firecracker, and you experience the sound mostly on your eardrums. (It can be pretty painful to be honest... ear protection definitely recommended.) But B2P a 16" round balloon and, even though the pressure is much lower when it bursts, the additional total energy that can be stored in the latex -- there is about 9-10 times as much latex in a 16" than a 5" balloon -- and the lower frequency means that this sound is a much deeper "bang" or "boom" that you experience both in your ears but also in your chest cavity, it kind of rings your body like a bell.

                And physiologically, our ears don't have a flat frequency response: generally, like high-quality microphones do, to a point they transmit higher frequencies to our brain more efficiently than lower ones. So the 16" balloon's lower boom, even though it's quite loud, is attenuated somewhat on the way to our brain... it doesn't sound as loud, or trigger ear pain as readily, as the 5" balloon's high crack. (Granted, this doesn't mean popping bigger balloons without ear protection is totally safe either... if anything the damage is probably the same but we're less likely to protect against it because it doesn't feel as damaging in the moment.)

                So in total... once we forget about the room environment, the two biggest factors in how loud a pop sounds are the balloon's pressure and its pitch. Balloons that are too small pop with unpleasant, higher-pitch sounds, but they have a lot of pressure so they also shred very well and generate a lot of power and intensity. Balloons that are too large make deep booms when they pop, but past a certain size it's rare that they can build up enough pressure to cross the "critical threshold" between slow zipper-popping and the dramatic shredding that generates more power.

                These two effects tend to "cross" somewhere between 14" and 24" rounds. Smaller, and you get more pressure, shredding, and intensity, but a higher-pitched and harsher bang. Larger, and you get a deeper and more satisfying boom but almost never the kind of intensity and shredding that adds to the thrill for most looners.

                And if you really want it loud... use a round balloon in this size range, with the thickest and most uniform latex you can find at that size, maximize the pressure by blowing it to burst, and do it in a still room with as many sound reflectors and as few sound absorbers as possible - like an empty racquetball court or poured-concrete stairwell. And keep your audiologist on speed dial.

                Comment

                • Seidenki
                  Senior Member
                  • Dec 2016
                  • 202

                  #9
                  Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                  That is a wonderful treatise!

                  I (very) recently had Belbal 14s and Unique 16s burst all on their own. Whilst neither were super tight, I had necked them both. The Belbal's were much more of an event - I could feel the pressure wave from 8 feet away. The Unique still had volume to the crack but not the pressure wave.

                  Comment

                  • Common Loon
                    Senior Member
                    • Aug 2020
                    • 232

                    #10
                    Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                    Yes! Belbal 14 really have a "bark" when they go... the latex is just so nice and strong, especially compared to Uniques.

                    Comment

                    • b0f0s0f
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2016
                      • 329

                      #11
                      Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                      Originally posted by Qbubbleballoon (:
                      Ooh, physics! I loooove physics!
                      Most think the "pop" sound that comes from the balloon bursting is the sound of the high pressure air escaping back to equilibrium with the ambient pressure but this is a common misconception. The "pop" is actually the high tension & energy of the latex returning back to it's relaxed state. It is an actual supersonic boom, believe it or not! Depending on the thickness and tension of the latex determines the loudness of the boom.

                      Cheers!
                      Do you have a source for this? Not necessarily refuting it but I've never seen any proof that this is the case. Water balloons, for instance, make no sound at all when they pop, and although it's possible that the water somehow attenuates the snap, I see no reason to assume necessarily that the pressure differential isn't involved. Particularly since the diameter of a balloon seems to correspond to the spectrum of its pop: https://asa.scitation.org/doi/10.1121/1.3518780

                      Comment

                      • srob2
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2017
                        • 552

                        #12
                        Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                        I've seen this and similar before. You have 2 sounds at almost the same time. The first is related to the size of the balloon, and almost always the same regardless of how inflated the balloon is, as long as it is inflated enough to pop. The 2nd is higher frequency and rises in volume and pitch as the balloon gets tighter - I believe this is from the latex shredding.

                        Take 2 16 inch balloons. Blow the first until it pops - you will hear and feel a loud, low "FOOM" and a louder, higher, sharper "CRACK!". Inflate the 2nd to just before the neck forms and stick a pin into it - almost the same "FOOM" but almost no "CRACK".

                        A smaller sized balloon will give less "FOOM" and more "CRACK". A bigger balloon might not get tight enough to "CRACK". A 9" b2p is so much louder than pin popping a normally inflated 9" A 36" inch b2p is much closer to a pin pop of the same balloon.
                        Last edited by srob2; 20-10-2021, 06:08.

                        Comment

                        • balloonpopper7
                          Member
                          • Oct 2020
                          • 30

                          #13
                          Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                          Popping by cigarette or lighter always makes sharper and louder boom, as the latex breaks from a point then spreads into all directions almost instantly.

                          Comment

                          • srob2
                            Senior Member
                            • Dec 2017
                            • 552

                            #14
                            Re: What factors contribute towards the 'loudness' of a bang?

                            I've always believed a pin pop could be louder than a b2p as long as the balloon is so tight it can't take another breath. A b2p typically bursts where the neck attaches to the body - typically launching most of the balloon as debris flying away from your face. But the latex has more tension in the bulb, so if that ruptures it completely shreds. You can also take an overinflated balloon and squeeze the just the neck so the bulb explodes

                            Comment

                            Working...