Anyone notice some balloons from one batch are just better?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • OverinflateThenRide
    Member
    • Dec 2025
    • 37

    Anyone notice some balloons from one batch are just better?

    So this is from a S2P perspective but I think it applies to other types of popping too.

    I feel like I see this kind of often. It’s not just one specific brand or anything. But I feel like when you get a new bag of balloons, there’s always a handful out of the bag that just take abuse for way longer than the others from the same bag. At first I thought it was specific colors but that idea was debunked by having multiples of one particular color take different levels of punishment before popping. So I’m confident it’s random. Has anyone noticed this? If so, any ideas why?

    I ask because my preferred method of popping is sit / bounce / ride to pop…and when I get one of these “special” loons….its awesome! To put this into perspective…the part I love most when riding is the balloon resisting popping…when it should have burst already That’s what gets me. So I dont sit on or bounce or ride my balloons to enjoy the ride or just to play. When I hop on top of a loon (which is almost always a bit overinflated), it’s immediately 100% rough abusive riding to get it to pop. And I’m about 200 lbs. So obviously many balloons pop fast. To deal with this, I usually inflate 8-10 or more of them in hopes that a few give a good ride before bursting. BUT THEN….you get one of these special balloons that take insane punishment and abuse before they pop (despite being overinflated). It’s a real treat! But is it possible to figure out which ones do it? Like are there signs you can look for to pick them out?

    I had a couple of these recently that absolutely blew my mind which is why I am posting this.

    First one was a pink TT24. It was the third balloon in the lineup of rides (on a carpeted floor). I hopped on and went to town…but it didn’t pop. I adjusted the loon so the neck was angled straight up in front of me (feels awesome) and continued the onslaught. I was riding so hard that I was almost loosing my balance so I had to put one hand against the wall. My other hand was kinda roughly controlling the neck and holding it against me. I was already being extremely rough and it was not popping. So I do my best to get even rougher, bouncing even higher, more wild. The balloon was squealing and creaking like crazy. At that point, I was bouncing so hard and high that I was almost getting completely off the balloon in mid air before crashing down with all my weight. I have decently flexible legs so when I crash down, I make sure the balloon takes the impacts, not my legs. And it was still not popping! In my mind, I’m just like “holy crap, this balloon is AWESOME!” And I can barely contain myself. But I still got even rougher with the neck…no nails or sharp objects…just held the neck tighter and I just kept going. I was in extacy going all out trying to pop this balloon….to the point that I was actually getting pretty winded. THEN…FINALLY… finally after a solid minute of that incredible experience, it popped. Tiny shards everywhere. And that’s another thing, I notice the better rides typically make shards instead of a few big pieces. Anyone else notice that too? But yeah, same batch, got the same experience with a red tt24. Again overinflated, high bouncing abusive riding to make it pop and it just lasted what seemed like forever. I’m only half way done with this bag of TT24s so I’m hoping for a couple more.

    I also have some BSA 17s that I like to ride on a weight bench. And doing it on the weight bench I think adds even more stress to the balloon…or at least it’s easier to put all your force into the balloon which I enjoy. The most recent one was a teal one, took the same level of abuse as the previously mentioned TT24s, except on a weight bench. Absolutely insane.

    What’s everyone else’s experiences with this? I cant be the only one that has noticed this.
  • CJLoo13
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2026
    • 181

    #2
    Definitely. Some you can see thin windows where you there's less colour and it's more see through I find they are usually weaker, it's just luck of the draw. Also what brand is BSA? Don't think I've heard of them

    Comment

    • Dallas Looner
      Mass-Pop Enthusiast
      • Dec 2017
      • 84

      #3
      Originally posted by CJLoo13
      Also what brand is BSA? Don't think I've heard of them
      They were a brand that was under the Pioneer Balloon Company (the people who owned Qualatex). BSA has long been gone if I remember correctly, pretty much ending production before the Qualatex brand stopped.

      Anywho back to what OP said: I noticed this issue the most with Tuftex. I personally noticed the quality of their balloons have drastically gone down for the average looner. I stopped buying TT for the most part due to this. Before they did their new branding of white bags, their old TT bags used to have some of the best balloons imaginable. The way the bulb of the balloon inflated, the somewhat thin yet strong layer of latex, and even up the neck of the balloon. It was called TUFtex for a reason. Some time after they introduced the white bags and after their acquisition of Qualatex liquidation, I noticed the quality of their TT products gone down. (I’ve only bought 17” at this time so I can’t speak much on the other product lines). While yes, the latex itself feels a bit stronger and somewhat tighter, but most of the balloons I’ve gotten since the rebranding and acquisition have usually prematurely popped. I’ve tested a new bag of crystal 17” and during inflation, nowhere close to letting the neck form, it prematurely popped. Also tried a new bag of standard color 17”, the neck formed a little better but also prematurely popped. Tried a older bag of standard color, the balloon was able to fully inflate.

      Its either I’m getting severely gaslit by my Tuftex theories or I just so happen to get strange batches.
      Texas y'all.

      Comment

      • lucid
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2016
        • 1174

        #4
        Oh yeah for sure I've noticed this as well. Not so much with sit popping. I don't even usually pop my own balloons at all, but I've noticed a difference in size and shape between batches or different packs. I bought more of those clear u16s with polkadots and they are shaped much different than what I'm used to. And they get much bigger before the neck starts to inflate. I actually much prefer these to all the other ones I have. I do wish I could get some that have red polkadots tho. I've seen plenty of pics and videos of these, but I've never gotten a single one.

        Another way I can tell is because my girl loves to pop my balloons. The vast majority of the time she'll pop then with her hands. Alot of times she'll slowly squeeze, digging her fingers in deeper until the balloon pops. She also likes to do this thing where she'll pinch the balloon and gently tug and pull at the tight latex until it pops. Sometimes they pop as soon as she does this one time. Other times she'll have to grab a whole handful of balloon and jerk like she's trying to start a lawnmower lol. The effort required for her to pop some balloons over others is very obvious. We've actually talked about this very thing.
        Alot of times we'll end up in wrestling matches to determine the fate of my balloons. Most of the time she'll have my balloon popped before I can take it away from her. Other times she struggles and I'm able to peel her hands off it and take it from her.

        Another go-to method for her is to pop them with her cigarettes. One of the craziest things ever, and I've seen it happen on two occasions now, one was recorded on video, is when she went to pop my balloon with a cigarette. The balloon didn't pop, but put out the cigarette! On the video we recorded, she was playing with a massive cloud of 10-15 big, and very tightly inflated helium balloons. She played nice with them and acted very sweet the whole video. But then at the end she lit a cigarette and attempted to rapid pop them all. Only about a quarter of the way through them, her cigarette was put out and she had to re-light it. She's probably done this hundreds of times, yet twice, the balloons won, for a second anyway.

        I've put a little thought into it, and the best I can come up with is that balloons are not manufactured scientifically with the exact variables going into each and every balloon. They all start out as a liquid latex sludge full of different chemicals that do different things. All these agents are poured into a magic swirling vat and distributed somewhat unevenly. So each balloon comes out with slightly different properties that would go largely unnoticed by pretty much everybody, except us looners .

        Comment

        • Dallas Looner
          Mass-Pop Enthusiast
          • Dec 2017
          • 84

          #5
          Originally posted by lucid
          So each balloon comes out with slightly different properties that would go largely unnoticed by pretty much everybody, except us looners .
          And probably professional decorators lol

          though, usually i see decorators inflating balloons far below their full potential. however, i'm sure they've had their great share of accidental/spontaneous pops from the variation in quality.
          Texas y'all.

          Comment

          • Kummelkopp
            Member
            • Feb 2025
            • 91

            #6
            First of all, hot story. Videos of such rough rides are ones I like the most.

            I am a strict non-popper, so I am not really experienced with shapes of shrads, but I could imagine that balloons where the stress is distributed evenly rupture at multiple spots at once, causing many shards.

            So material defects, different material thicknesses or for example pin or nail pops lead to very uneven stresses and making lesser shrads.
            Just my theory

            Comment

            • Thinskinned
              Look Out!
              • Jul 2024
              • 247

              #7
              Originally posted by lucid
              Oh yeah for sure I've noticed this as well. Not so much with sit popping. I don't even usually pop my own balloons at all, but I've noticed a difference in size and shape between batches or different packs. I bought more of those clear u16s with polkadots and they are shaped much different than what I'm used to. And they get much bigger before the neck starts to inflate. I actually much prefer these to all the other ones I have. I do wish I could get some that have red polkadots tho. I've seen plenty of pics and videos of these, but I've never gotten a single one.

              Another way I can tell is because my girl loves to pop my balloons. The vast majority of the time she'll pop then with her hands. Alot of times she'll slowly squeeze, digging her fingers in deeper until the balloon pops. She also likes to do this thing where she'll pinch the balloon and gently tug and pull at the tight latex until it pops. Sometimes they pop as soon as she does this one time. Other times she'll have to grab a whole handful of balloon and jerk like she's trying to start a lawnmower lol. The effort required for her to pop some balloons over others is very obvious. We've actually talked about this very thing.
              Alot of times we'll end up in wrestling matches to determine the fate of my balloons. Most of the time she'll have my balloon popped before I can take it away from her. Other times she struggles and I'm able to peel her hands off it and take it from her.

              Another go-to method for her is to pop them with her cigarettes. One of the craziest things ever, and I've seen it happen on two occasions now, one was recorded on video, is when she went to pop my balloon with a cigarette. The balloon didn't pop, but put out the cigarette! On the video we recorded, she was playing with a massive cloud of 10-15 big, and very tightly inflated helium balloons. She played nice with them and acted very sweet the whole video. But then at the end she lit a cigarette and attempted to rapid pop them all. Only about a quarter of the way through them, her cigarette was put out and she had to re-light it. She's probably done this hundreds of times, yet twice, the balloons won, for a second anyway.

              I've put a little thought into it, and the best I can come up with is that balloons are not manufactured scientifically with the exact variables going into each and every balloon. They all start out as a liquid latex sludge full of different chemicals that do different things. All these agents are poured into a magic swirling vat and distributed somewhat unevenly. So each balloon comes out with slightly different properties that would go largely unnoticed by pretty much everybody, except us looners .
              Real talk I picked up a bag of the U16s with polkadots (from extralooners US clearance sale fwiw) and the only one I've inflated so far has been absolutely ENORMOUS. I didn't measure it but its gotta be at least 20" and I stopped blowing as I was sure it was going to pop, but it wasn't even really firm. I don't know if the neck was even going to come out before the balloon popped and I wasn't wearing my earplugs so I erred on the side of caution.

              Comment

              • lucid
                Senior Member
                • Sep 2016
                • 1174

                #8
                YES!!! That's where I got mine too.

                Thats pretty crazy ain't it? I thought the same thing at 1st. Aint no way thats 16 inches lol.

                I thought for sure that they may well get that big, but they're gonna eventually pop. Nope. I blew up one as big as a tuftex 24 and tied it off. It's been several days now and it still hasn't popped. And like you said, somehow they're still pretty squishy. They've easily become my favorite balloons of all time.



                Every other pack I've gotten up to this point have also been like that to a degree. Its just that this last pack had 15-20 percent more of everything that makes them great.

                Did you get any with red or dark blue polkadots? They have them in the pics, and I've seen them in videos, but I've never gotten one in my packs. I've not gotten brown polkadots either, but I'm glad for that haha.

                Comment

                • Thinskinned
                  Look Out!
                  • Jul 2024
                  • 247

                  #9
                  I didnt check but I'll let you know

                  Comment

                  Working...