ethics of public popping

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • AJK64
    Moderator
    • Jun 2018
    • 1280

    #31
    Originally posted by Merl

    No. Wrong again. I understand exactly what's been said. I'm not creating straw men, I'm just expanding upon the point.

    What I'm saying is...it's the same antisocial behavior as in our prior discussion, the one where a few members here bragged of getting off on stealing and destroying public displays?

    Remember that discussion? The one where you defended them? Now you're doing the same thing here.

    See, my point is, for most people, including several looners here, it doesn't matter if the balloon is freely given out. At all.

    They correctly view the guy who ON PURPOSE pops FREE balloons in public (where popping isn't a normally expected thing) as the same type of rude asshole as the guy who destroys public displays. Both guys get off at the expense of other people's enjoyment.

    Not only do these assholes know this, they don't care. They want to go home and masturbate to the memory of being an asshole at everyone else's expense.

    Sane thing here. It doesn't matter if the balloon was free. That's irrelevant. SOCIALLY, there's no difference between the two and you're defending both.

    I know you already saw that is my point. But once again, more people here disagree with you than agree with you.

    You might want to ask yourself why.
    Arguing in a post about what was said on a completely different post isn't how this all works. That's called bad faith arguing. Also, please don't call anyone an asshole... That's not cool. Also the whole "more people like my post than yours" thing is fine when you're 12 years old. You haven't been 12 in a long long time so stop it. Posts such as this are not about who is right or wrong, but about people's opinions. You are very entitled to your opinion, as are other users. But your opinion is no better than any one else's... That's a valuable thing to remember.
    Last edited by AJK64; 05-03-2024, 11:30.

    Comment

    • Guest

      #32
      Originally posted by AJK64

      If you understood Lucids point, why did you use the words "popping decor balloons" when that wasn't the subject of his post?
      One more time.

      I mentioned decor balloons since they came up before re: antisocial public popping. It ties in here.

      Because in most public places, it doesn't matter what the balloons are there for or whose balloons they are. Decorations or freebies, almost no one wants them popped, nor wants to hear them popped.

      More people than me have been saying so on this thread. If you still don't understand why, I can't help you

      ​​​

      Comment

      • Guest

        #33
        Originally posted by AJK64
        "more people like my post than yours"
        Is that what I wrote?

        Comment

        • AJK64
          Moderator
          • Jun 2018
          • 1280

          #34
          Originally posted by Merl

          Is that what I wrote?
          "more people here disagree with you than agree with you."

          Is what you wrote yes.

          Comment

          • Guest

            #35
            Originally posted by AJK64

            "more people here disagree with you than agree with you."

            Is what you wrote yes.
            So "more people like my post than yours" is not what I wrote. Thanks for clarifying that.

            Comment

            • Kitten
              Senior Member
              • Jul 2023
              • 548

              #36
              You've both stated your points, there's no point in going around in circles. This was supposed to be a discussion to see what other people think, not a thread for arguing.

              You won't change each others mind. Internet arguments like this never get resolved.

              Comment

              • Guest

                #37
                Agreed.

                I just don't like moderators taking sides in discussions where they accuse a user of bad faith while the mod makes false accusations about the user.

                Anyway, perhaps you can add a poll...

                SHOULD POPPING BE OKAY IN ANY PUBLIC SETTING?

                or something like that.

                Comment

                • AJK64
                  Moderator
                  • Jun 2018
                  • 1280

                  #38
                  I'm not taking sides merely stating my own "opinion". And the reason I reprimanded you was you were implying that you are right. You even used the popularity fallacy. You then insulted people on the forum. That is unreasonable.

                  Kitten, I was trying to keep the post on topic rather than allowing a user with a history of causing trouble in posts by asserting that he is the moral superior of other users, when he us no such thing. He is simply another user, no better.

                  Merl. This is a formal warning. Keep to what people are actually saying in here instead if referring to old posts from a year ago to try and make a point. Also if you insult ANY member of this forum instead keeping things civil when you argue, you will be banned. Thankyou.

                  Comment

                  • Kitten
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2023
                    • 548

                    #39
                    That seems fair. I wasn't aware this was an old issue. A poll could work, but it greatly depends on situation. I think common sense is needed. Popping someone's display is very different to popping a balloon someone has given out. Obviously depends on the situation too. Popping a balloon in a quiet library is obviously a dick move.

                    Comment

                    • Guest

                      #40
                      Or in a bank, where they are often displayed and given away.

                      Comment

                      • Falcon
                        Senior Member
                        • Jun 2023
                        • 170

                        #41
                        Since the op was asking for honest opinions on public popping, I'll throw in my 2 cents. It really depends on the circumstance. In her particular case, I agree with her and it should not have been done.

                        1) It's a restaurant, people are there to eat, not party. Additionally it's a restaurant where parents take their children. I for one would not feel very good about upsetting a child. Finally in a restaurant you can't get away if it upsets you or your children.

                        2) Outside, in a bar, in the open areas of a mall or at a party. Have a blast. People have the option to avoid the situation and/or are in a place where it's expected.

                        In the op's situation, had I been there with with my children, I would have said something. Sure mistakes happen, and kids don't know better, but adults should try to be more considerant of others and their surroundings.

                        Comment

                        • Kitten
                          Senior Member
                          • Jul 2023
                          • 548

                          #42
                          Originally posted by Falcon
                          Since the op was asking for honest opinions on public popping, I'll throw in my 2 cents. It really depends on the circumstance. In her particular case, I agree with her and it should not have been done.

                          1) It's a restaurant, people are there to eat, not party. Additionally it's a restaurant where parents take their children. I for one would not feel very good about upsetting a child. Finally in a restaurant you can't get away if it upsets you or your children.

                          2) Outside, in a bar, in the open areas of a mall or at a party. Have a blast. People have the option to avoid the situation and/or are in a place where it's expected.

                          In the op's situation, had I been there with with my children, I would have said something. Sure mistakes happen, and kids don't know better, but adults should try to be more considerant of others and their surroundings.

                          I agree and I'll be having a chat with my friend to make sure they only do it in open areas from now on. I'll admit it was fun to experience, but it certainly doesn't need to be repeated.

                          Comment

                          • Guest

                            #43
                            Originally posted by Kitten
                            That seems fair. I wasn't aware this was an old issue. A poll could work, but it greatly depends on situation. I think common sense is needed. Popping someone's display is very different to popping a balloon someone has given out.
                            Just so we're clear, here's context:

                            There are members here, a definite minority, who have said it is okay to steal and/or pop any balloon or inflatable anywhere they see it, just for their own sexual arousal. One even said the important thing was not respect for the property of others, but only that he was able to get away with it. Nothing mattered to him except getting off on the thrill.

                            Here's the weird thing.

                            Some of the same people here excusing public rudeness were defending theft and vandalism on that old thread. This pathological selfishness, "If I wanna pop it, to hell with everyone around me" is the exact same attitude...lack of concern for others.

                            That is why I brought up the old discussion, because it is very much related to this one.

                            Comment

                            • srob2
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2017
                              • 552

                              #44
                              It matters who's balloon it is and how it got there. If I go into a public restaurant, and they have a display of balloons, and I pop them, I am an asshole for destroying their display and disturbing customers. If I bring my own balloons and pop them, I am still an asshole, because even though they are my balloons, it is not my restaurant. If I own the restaurant and pop my own balloons, there is nothing wrong with that, even if it offends or scares customers, except I might lose business. If I give balloons to customers and tell them to pop them, it is the same thing. If I hand out balloons without telling people whether to pop them or not, a significant number of people are going to pop them, and if I don't know that, I am going to learn it quickly.

                              Comment

                              • Guest

                                #45
                                You're right, it depends on the setting but I wouldn't bet most adults will pop a balloon just because the owner hands it out for free. Kids are likely who will be given balloons and we know a kid usually hangs onto a balloon for as long as they can before popping, if they pop it at all. Women are kind of the same, if they accept one in the first place. They might pop it if others do first. Most men won't even accept one.

                                But it could happen.

                                Comment

                                Working...