ethics of public popping

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Guest

    #16
    Originally posted by Kitten
    fire crackers
    I hadn't considered this. These days, sadly, we know how people will instantly react to any kind of bang, and it's known that they sometimes reacted the same to balloons popping.

    Comment

    • Kitten
      Senior Member
      • Jul 2023
      • 548

      #17
      Originally posted by Merl

      I hadn't considered this. These days, sadly, we know how people will instantly react to any kind of bang, and it's known that they sometimes reacted the same to balloons popping.
      That isn't an issue in the UK where I'm from as gun crime is extremely rare. I don't think we actually have fire crakers here either.

      Comment

      • Benjy
        Member
        • Mar 2018
        • 84

        #18
        Inflatables rather than balloons, but I get annoyed by certain kinds of public popping of them. If a toy gets punctured or outright burst when being played with, or by accident, that's one thing. Hell, if people are playing rough with their lilo's or things with the intention of popping them, again, that's up to them.
        What winds me up are the intentional but unnescessary pops; people at the end of the day who can't be bothered deflating toys. I get not wanting to litter or leave something on the beach, but how hard is it to offer that unwanted ball or swim ring to someone nearby, as opposed to jabbing a hole in it and binning it? I'll admit to seeing less of that sort of thing in recent years (mainly because you get fewer inflatables at the beach compared to when I was a kid), but I still witness it sometimes, and it annoys me quite a lot...

        Comment

        • OneTrickPony
          Senior Member
          • Feb 2024
          • 170

          #19
          Originally posted by Benjy
          Inflatables rather than balloons, but I get annoyed by certain kinds of public popping of them. If a toy gets punctured or outright burst when being played with, or by accident, that's one thing. Hell, if people are playing rough with their lilo's or things with the intention of popping them, again, that's up to them.
          What winds me up are the intentional but unnescessary pops; people at the end of the day who can't be bothered deflating toys. I get not wanting to litter or leave something on the beach, but how hard is it to offer that unwanted ball or swim ring to someone nearby, as opposed to jabbing a hole in it and binning it? I'll admit to seeing less of that sort of thing in recent years (mainly because you get fewer inflatables at the beach compared to when I was a kid), but I still witness it sometimes, and it annoys me quite a lot...
          Wow, people really just leave behind or just pop their inflatables when leaving the beach/pool?
          MAybe because I'm from a different country and inflatables can be a little expensive(not extremely but you know, something you take at least minimum care of and use again), and we even use the popped ones, if you can still inflate it, you can still use it, even people with money.
          ​​​​
          Sorry for the rant, but it's literally the first time I heard of that.
          "It's dangerous to go alone! Take this."
          ​
          * You obtained 1 Balloon *

          Comment

          • lucid
            Senior Member
            • Sep 2016
            • 1174

            #20
            Originally posted by srob2
            McDonald's is a for-profit business that chose to give out balloons knowing some will get popped on purpose by customers.
            Can confirm this. I worked at McDonald's back in the day when helium balloons were commonplace in there. The one I worked at was directly across from a high school that I also attended at the time. The balloons got popped in there all the time. Not daily, but at least on a weekly occurrence. Usually everybody would jump and then laugh. Nobody ever seemed to get offended or upset. Especially me lol.

            Does anybody else find it amusing that we are talking about balloons here but are discussing it as if we are debating whether or not it's moral to release a canister of mustard gas in public lol? It's certainly not worth attacking each other over.
            Last edited by lucid; 05-03-2024, 19:03.

            Comment

            • srob2
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2017
              • 552

              #21
              Originally posted by Kitten
              It seems like people have very different views on this topic. I don't think the "balloons are meant to be popped" and the "not everyone is phobic" excuses work well.
              Change the scenario a bit and add something like fire crackers instead of balloons. People are going to be disturbed by the sound, even if they aren't nervous around balloons.

              All that said, I think most phobics will avoid a small building that is full of balloons, because accidents (and intentional pops) do happen. I've witnessed balloons popping in restaurants before. It's going to happen at some point if they have balloons out a lot.

              I think I'll stick to outdoor areas and places that are already loud. If there's balloons and noise, I don't think it'll be a problem, and outdoor pops aren't as loud and you can see and avoid it.
              Much better example than drinking straws. If a for-profit restaurant hands fire crackers to patrons as they arrive, without asking them not to set them off or posting signs, then I don't think a customer that sets one off on purpose is doing anything wrong even if they offend other patrons.

              Comment

              • Guest

                #22
                Originally posted by lucid

                Can confirm this. I worked at McDonald's back in the day when helium balloons were commonplace in there. The one I worked at was directly across from a high school
                The people who would be most offended by popping were already avoiding that crush of noisy kids anyway.

                I live near a huge multi-billion dollar retirement area. Everyone is well into white hair age range. Popping decor balloons in a McDonalds there will not get a similar understanding response. Staff will tell them to stop or tell them to leave.

                Comment

                • Guest

                  #23
                  Hey, here's a simple experiment that could bury this debate for good.

                  ​​​Q. What is the one place where you know balloons are an everyday item AND the people working there fully accept that a balloon can pop?

                  A. Why, at stores which will inflate and sell you balloons, of course!

                  So here's all you have to do...

                  Go into such a business.

                  Deliberately pop part of their inflated balloon displays.

                  Make sure they see you doing it. Smile.

                  Note their reaction.

                  Repeat, again making sure they see you do it. Say, "Balloons are made to be popped!" or "Well, you know they were eventually going to be thrown away anyway." Pop another.

                  Report back here on the positive responses you get.

                  Comment

                  • AJK64
                    Moderator
                    • Jun 2018
                    • 1280

                    #24
                    Originally posted by Merl

                    The people who would be most offended by popping were already avoiding that crush of noisy kids anyway.

                    I live near a huge multi-billion dollar retirement area. Everyone is well into white hair age range. Popping decor balloons in a McDonalds there will not get a similar understanding response. Staff will tell them to stop or tell them to leave.
                    I don't think you understand. These are not balloons for decor, they are balloons handed out to members of the public by mc Donald's for those e peole to do what they want with those balloons.

                    Comment

                    • AJK64
                      Moderator
                      • Jun 2018
                      • 1280

                      #25
                      Originally posted by Merl
                      Hey, here's a simple experiment that could bury this debate for good.

                      Q. What is the one place where you know balloons are an everyday item AND the people working there fully accept that a balloon can pop?

                      A. Why, at stores which will inflate and sell you balloons, of course!

                      So here's all you have to do...

                      Go into such a business.

                      Deliberately pop part of their inflated balloon displays.

                      Make sure they see you doing it. Smile.

                      Note their reaction.

                      Repeat, again making sure they see you do it. Say, "Balloons are made to be popped!" or "Well, you know they were eventually going to be thrown away anyway." Pop another.

                      Report back here on the positive responses you get.
                      Again. I don't think you understand the points being made here. These are not people saying to burst balloons that are a part of decor or displays, they are saying that balloons given out to people by businesses are expected as part of the handing out process to be burst by some of those they are given to because... Part of the reason a balloon exists for most people ole is to be burst.

                      You are creating straw man arguments not based on what the vast majority of those you are arguing with are even stating.
                      Last edited by AJK64; 05-03-2024, 04:15.

                      Comment

                      • lukmanrewa
                        Senior Member
                        • Jun 2012
                        • 491

                        #26
                        Well yes, balloons do pop. But when you purposely do a b2p inside a restaurant or a mall for your own fun, then indeed you're an asshole. Simple as that.

                        Comment

                        • Guest

                          #27
                          Originally posted by AJK64

                          I don't think you understand. These are not balloons for decor, they are balloons handed out to members of the public by mc Donald's for those e peole to do what they want with those balloons.
                          No, I totally understand that's your point.
                          Last edited by Guest; 05-03-2024, 08:08.

                          Comment

                          • Guest

                            #28
                            Originally posted by AJK64
                            Again. I don't think you understand the points being made here. These are not people saying to burst balloons that are a part of decor or displays...You are creating straw man arguments
                            No. Wrong again. I understand exactly what's been said. I'm not creating straw men, I'm just expanding upon the point.

                            What I'm saying is...it's the same antisocial behavior as in our prior discussion, the one where a few members here bragged of getting off on stealing and destroying public displays?

                            Remember that discussion? The one where you defended them? Now you're doing the same thing here.

                            See, my point is, for most people, including several looners here, it doesn't matter if the balloon is freely given out. At all.

                            They correctly view the guy who ON PURPOSE pops FREE balloons in public (where popping isn't a normally expected thing) as the same type of rude asshole as the guy who destroys public displays. Both guys get off at the expense of other people's enjoyment.

                            Not only do these assholes know this, they don't care. They want to go home and masturbate to the memory of being an asshole at everyone else's expense.

                            Sane thing here. It doesn't matter if the balloon was free. That's irrelevant. SOCIALLY, there's no difference between the two and you're defending both.

                            I know you already saw that is my point. But once again, more people here disagree with you than agree with you.

                            You might want to ask yourself why.
                            Last edited by Guest; 05-03-2024, 08:20.

                            Comment

                            • Guest

                              #29
                              Originally posted by Casey88
                              Well yes, balloons do pop. But when you purposely do a b2p inside a restaurant or a mall for your own fun, then indeed you're an asshole. Simple as that.
                              But Casey! If the balloon was given to you FREE, then it's okay to pop it wherever you are because it's yours!

                              [that's the basic point being made by a few people here, so thank you for getting what this is really about]

                              Comment

                              • AJK64
                                Moderator
                                • Jun 2018
                                • 1280

                                #30
                                Originally posted by Merl

                                No, I totally understand that's your point.
                                If you understood Lucids point, why did you use the words "popping decor balloons" when that wasn't the subject of his post?

                                Comment

                                Working...