Do Ho gyi toys sell product clones of well known inflatables

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • O'Dragon
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2024
    • 298

    Do Ho gyi toys sell product clones of well known inflatables

    Hello,

    i was browsing the web searching foe inflatables when I stumbled upon the site of Hongyi toys again and found a few very well known toys like a Puffypaws Zenith dragon.
    Given that the Zenith is no longer for sale on Puffypaws site I assume this is a clone?
    So I wondered if anyone ever tried one of those offers? Im really curious what one would get in the end.
    Because if its a 1:1 clone wouldnt this be copyright infringement and if so why are these factories not facing copyright infringement law suits if they’re really just cloning another product?

    Is it just because the original manufacturers decided not to sue or is there a loophole that these companies use?

    maybe so eone k ows something about this?

    Have a great week!
  • Inflatable18
    Member
    • Jul 2023
    • 32

    #2
    I know the guy that commissioned the Zenith, it’s almost exactly 1:1. He spent a lot of time working with Hongyi on it to make sure of that. And I know a few other folks that bought them, they’re good toys from what I hear, as long as you ask Hongyi for better vinyl than the material they make them with by default so it doesn’t feel like a raincoat.

    As far as why it happens, manufacturers know about it, and they will send nastygrams to the companies that do it, but they can’t do much other than that. Chinese courts really don’t give an F unless you’re a Chinese company and will dismiss foreign claims against domestic companies unless you have a TON of money, IE Apple.

    As far as why people do it, it’s a mixture 2 things I think:
    1. The company that owns the design doesn’t want to do special run-offs
    2. The company that owns the design doesn’t make it anymore/doesn’t sell it consistently.
    a lot of puffypaws toys are made because of number 2. But for me personally, it was number 1.

    I wanted a green warm blood, but HP will not make one-offs for any of their “stock” toys for god only knows what reason. So when they were asked they said no. Although tbh I wouldn’t want to buy one from them anyway considering how crap the quality of their stuff is. I suddenly had a lot of money to spend, and I knew where the horses were made… So, I just did it myself.

    First version by the actual factory HP hired was not what I was hoping for though, they used transparent PVC and painted it green… So I had to take the design (which for some reason I was just… given, lol) to a different factory that had the material I wanted. The final horse turned out amazing, and I couldn’t be happier with the finished horse.

    Comment

    • Equui-Nox
      Senior Member
      • Nov 2017
      • 186

      #3
      Don’t use Hongyi to make ripoffs of designs in the inflatable community. Most people do not like it, its no better than the people feeding art into AI to generate free art instead of commissioning the original artists. Wait for the next run, and if you can’t do that, message PuffyPaws or PhenodToy directly and ask about doing a one-off (HP will not do it).They will work with you as long as you are willing to put up the capital for it. And if you still can’t get the toy and aren’t willing to be patient for an official run, then suck it up like the rest of us, you can’t always have your cake and eat it too. See if someone has a used one for sale maybe (do NOT buy off Ebay, find group chats on Telegram).

      I know a lot of people who run inflatable panels don’t even allow cloned toys in and will boot you out for it. If you want to clone a toy and make mods to it, do it to a typical store-bought toy.

      Don’t contribute to the issue, don’t be a part of the problem.

      Comment

      • ricky
        Member
        • May 2017
        • 95

        #4
        I understand the importance of intellectual property right, but it just blows my mind how some of these custom inflatable companies are so lax about doing new runs of popular toys or just abandoning amazing designs completely. Not sure why they do it, is it an attempt to keep the market inflated (pun intended) so that they can make massive margins on each toy? It seems like that, I can't really think of many other reasons why they would leave so much potential money on the table otherwise. Maybe I'm just bitter about being in a constant layoff cycle in my industry, but I just can't bring myself to get too mad over clone manufacturers. Business is super competitive and brutal these days, the best deterrent from clones is for authentic manufacturers to buckle down and ramp up production heavily when demand is widely unfulfilled. Lot of people wish they had that kind of opportunity to make an almost guaranteed large profit.

        Comment

        • ChillinHaze
          Senior Member
          • Sep 2016
          • 143

          #5
          No, these companies often don't make much profit from the pre-order runs. If they don't get enough orders runs might even get canceled or the prices go up per unit. On the other side if a pre-order gets lots of units ordered prices will get lowered. The profit often then goes into designing new stuff. As to why some designs don't get run again is also sometimes quite simple, the company doesn't hold the right to the design. They often collaborate with artists and the rights to the designs are then held by the artists. That's for example why some PuffyPaws toys won't get re-run, because PuffyPaws is not holding the rights for them.

          Comment

          • Equui-Nox
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2017
            • 186

            #6
            What ChillinHaze said. The “really cool and in-demand” toys are often ones designed off of people’s fursonas/characters, so in order for a run to happen, they have to give their blessing for it, and sometimes depending on various drama happenings, this is impossible to get.

            designs owned by the makers, however, are easier to run but the issue therein lies that an additional run of the toy won’t happen until enough interest is garnered that they can guarantee a lower price. This may take time, depending on the toy.

            Comment

            • O'Dragon
              Senior Member
              • Jan 2024
              • 298

              #7
              Thanks for this insight.
              I already feared that one of the reasons could be the lack of interest of the Chinese court.

              Yeah I personally also wouldn’t go for a clone even though I soooo want a Zenith dragon and a few of the puffy paws toys.
              As it seems to me that there are many more people interested in the rare toys that are produced I’m asking myself now if it is
              1. maybe most and for all a lack of publicity that keeps the production runs low? If more people would know in time about them maybe there would be more orders?
              2. the high price? I mean yeah of course a cheaper toy will always have higher chances of getting more buyers than a pricey one but still I‘d be interested to know how much this factor would contribute to the order amount if the pre order runs where more publicly known?

              I finally decided to start making my own toy a few weeks ago, also based on my sona, so I‘m gathering information about the process at the moment, so maybe I can say more about the challenges manufacturers face in a few weeks/months.

              Comment

              • ChillinHaze
                Senior Member
                • Sep 2016
                • 143

                #8
                Well, the runs are known quite well but you always have to keep in mind that this field is a niche interest. The prices are high, because the toys often have rather complex builds requiring a lot of reinforcement and have pretty low unit numbers per run. Normal mass produced toys are made in so high batches the custom runs just can't reach. Plus, the material and machinery used for making them are actually quite expensive, too. We're kinda lucky the workers get paid very poorly compared to western countries or the prices would go even higher.

                I understand wanting to have a nice big, possible dream toy for an affordable amount of money but in the end this is a luxury. Many hobbies will turn into something you need to invest money and time into the further you go and inflatables are no exception to that. Patience and only buying want you really want were always the way to go with custom inflatables. Lots of people just want everything at once and then either overspend, buy stuff they never really inflate or are like griefing after every toy they couldn't get. Some even get choice paralysis and never buy anything they actually want and then complain about not having the toys they want. All just because they can't limit themselves to the few toys at the top of their priority list.

                It's really know what you want, save the money and keeping a smaller collection of really coveted inflatables beats hoarding masses you mostly never use. But that's just my two cents about it ^^

                Comment

                • Big Thud Joe
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2017
                  • 407

                  #9
                  Originally posted by ChillinHaze
                  . All just because they can't limit themselves to the few toys at the top of their priority list.

                  It's really know what you want, save the money and keeping a smaller collection of really coveted inflatables beats hoarding masses you mostly never use. But that's just my two cents about it ^^
                  Yes this, I guess I'm lucky that the kind of things that arouse me are rather quite simple to make and so few things. As far as PVC inflatables, I mainly get turned on by 48 inch beach balls, and life size human like inflatable characters, and already having a relationship with a reliable chinese manufacturer helps a long way.

                  Comment

                  • TheMole
                    Senior Member
                    • Nov 2019
                    • 302

                    #10
                    TL;DR without all the quibbling about intellectual property rights...

                    Yes, they certainly will. And in my experience the quality is actually superior if you let HongYi know you want it to be tough and have seams reinforced. I had a run of *red dragons you mentioned* made (3 for personal use and to make sure I have in the future) and they're really nice!

                    These "premium" inflatable companies should be smart enough to figure out that folks will find alternatives and turn to the EXACT SAME manufacturers they use when they want to upcharge 400-500% for what is essentially a delicate toy.

                    Comment

                    • ChillinHaze
                      Senior Member
                      • Sep 2016
                      • 143

                      #11
                      The quality is superior? Definitely not. Hongyi has production issues left and right. Paint is still an issue, missalingnment and sometimes ugly seamwork. You just told us you bought 3 copy toys from them so you have for the future. That already tells me you are not confident in the quality.

                      The gen 2 Zenith I bought from PP 2018 has had no issues at all so far. These toys will last very long and even longer if you know your basic inflatable maintenance stuff.

                      Also, stop spewing nonsense about upcharging 500%. The companies like PP, ICF, Phenod etc. are actually doing a lot of quality control and adjustments so that the toys come out as best as possible. These companies consist off people from the community, they know the struggle of affording nice toys and like it was stated earlier in this thread, most of these pre-oder runs don't turn a profit at all or just very small ones which will be used for designing new inflatables.

                      If you want to support the community just don't be a cheapskate and buy copy toys. There's nothing against doing an original design through Hongyi, it's your choice which factory you want to use for that but going for the rip-offs is just plain shitty behavior and in the end hurts the community when people like PP stop making stuff because of that.

                      Comment

                      • OverTheTop
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2013
                        • 749

                        #12
                        Originally posted by ChillinHaze
                        The quality is superior? Definitely not. Hongyi has production issues left and right. Paint is still an issue, missalingnment and sometimes ugly seamwork. You just told us you bought 3 copy toys from them so you have for the future. That already tells me you are not confident in the quality.

                        The gen 2 Zenith I bought from PP 2018 has had no issues at all so far. These toys will last very long and even longer if you know your basic inflatable maintenance stuff.

                        Also, stop spewing nonsense about upcharging 500%. The companies like PP, ICF, Phenod etc. are actually doing a lot of quality control and adjustments so that the toys come out as best as possible. These companies consist off people from the community, they know the struggle of affording nice toys and like it was stated earlier in this thread, most of these pre-oder runs don't turn a profit at all or just very small ones which will be used for designing new inflatables.

                        If you want to support the community just don't be a cheapskate and buy copy toys. There's nothing against doing an original design through Hongyi, it's your choice which factory you want to use for that but going for the rip-offs is just plain shitty behavior and in the end hurts the community when people like PP stop making stuff because of that.
                        Agreed - the quality can be pretty good if you choose the right manufacturer, provide a solid design reference, and make sure they use high quality materials and manufacturing techniques, but at that point you're essentially just doing the same thing that companies like IW and Puffypaws do, just with a side of plagiarism. I definitely wouldn't expect superior quality unless you're really putting in the work, and Hongyi in particular is notorious for poor design/art work, stiff vinyl, and low quality printing.

                        Comment

                        • inbox_pm
                          Senior Member
                          • Apr 2017
                          • 189

                          #13
                          I have such clone - an "Angel Wings" mattress, an improved copy of Funboy design. I's very cool that such clones exists! In such way a great toys becomes available even for our poor country (yes, I bought it on our local marketplace few years ago, before the war). Also, they can be better in some parameters then original. Mine have a "rapid" valves instead a usual "double" ones, inflates and deflates fast and easy.
                          IMG_7440.jpg
                          IMG_7442.jpg
                          Attached Files

                          Comment

                          Working...