Helium inflatables

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • raka
    Junior Member
    • Nov 2023
    • 12

    Helium inflatables

    few days ago, a thought got into my head.

    if balloons can use helium, can inflatables do so too?

    to be frank, i wanted to test it out, but i don't have the money nor the space to buy a helium tank.

    maybe some of you here has any experience? or maybe some thoughts on it? if so, i would love to hear them. thanks!
  • Trakil
    Member
    • Aug 2024
    • 89

    #2
    I think it would be a bit tricky to inflate an inflatable with helium and it most likely wouldn't fly so it seems pointless really

    Comment

    • raka
      Junior Member
      • Nov 2023
      • 12

      #3
      Originally posted by Trakil
      I think it would be a bit tricky to inflate an inflatable with helium and it most likely wouldn't fly so it seems pointless really
      makes sense. just wondering if anyone has done it anyway.

      Comment

      • WaterWings
        Member
        • Mar 2018
        • 44

        #4
        I wonder if it would work with something that had been really heat-stretched until really thing

        Comment

        • cl23
          Senior Member
          • May 2022
          • 381

          #5
          Originally posted by WaterWings
          I wonder if it would work with something that had been really heat-stretched until really thing
          This is most likely the only chance, you can get an inflatable floating. Use a larger beach ball, heat-stretch it as much, as possible, fill with helium.

          BUT before filling with helium, calculate the volume of the stretched ball and measure its weight. You can calculate, how much weight the amount of helium, that fits inside the ball can lift. If it's more, than the weight of the ball, it will float, otherwise, it won't. It's as simple as that.

          Comment

          • Trakil
            Member
            • Aug 2024
            • 89

            #6
            If anything would have a chance of floating it would be a Very stretched ball, alternatively one could try with hydrogen but then you'd be just making a bomb basically

            Comment

            • zycram
              Senior Member
              • Nov 2024
              • 408

              #7
              Actually there is a video with it. A super stretched beach ball may float if you inflate it with helium.
              Alternatively, you may calculate the volume of some huge pool toys and try to overinflate them with helium. If e,g, an oversized beach ball is big enough it will float because its mass grows with the square of the diamater while its volume is cubed.

              Comment

              • Bass Boll
                Senior Member
                • Jun 2023
                • 211

                #8
                The geometric shape with the best volume-to-surface ratio is a sphere - this recommends a beach ball if you want to see something lifting up. But:

                - The density of air under normal (sea level) pressure and at 20°C is 1.204 kg/m³.
                - The density of helium under the same conditions is 0.166 kg/m³.
                This would mean a specific buoyancy of 1.204 - 0.166 = 1.038 kg/m³, but as standard "balloon gas" grade helium is just about 96% pure we may calculate by 1 kg/m³.

                Question: How big must a beach ball be to contain enough helium to just float in the air?

                This means the buoyancy F_b must equal the weight F_w.
                - The buoyancy is given by volume V times the specific buoyancy D_up times the gravitational acceleration g.
                The weight is the weight of the PVC which more or less resembles the surface:
                - The weight is given by the surface A times the thickness of the vinyl d times the specific density of PVC D_pvc times the gravitational acceleration g.

                Now we can formalize:
                F_b = V · D_up · g
                F_w = A · d · D_pvc · g

                F_b = F_w
                V · D_up · g = A · d · D_pvc · g | The gravitational acceleration g cancels out immediately.
                V · D_up = A · d · D_pvc | Replace V and A by their radius-based formulas.
                4/3 π r³ · D_up = 4 π r² · d · D_pvc | Divide by 4 π r².
                1/3 r · D_up = d · D_pvc | Multiply by 3 and divide by D_up.
                r = 3 · d · D_pvc/D_up

                Now we can insert the numbers. The thickness of the PVC shall be assumed 0.25 mm ("10-gauge vinyl"), a reasonable value for big beach balls. (Yes I know, Shosu sell BBB with only 0.18 mm.) The density of soft PVC is about 1.3 g/cm³ or 1300 kg/m³. This yields:

                r = 3 · 0.00025 m · 1300 kg/m³ / 1 kg/m³ = 3 · 0.00025 m · 1300 = 0.975 m

                Answer: A standard material beach ball needs to have a diameter of 2 r = 1.95 m or 6 ft 4¾ in. As beach ball sizes are measured uninflated, i.e. along the half circumference, and given in inches, this would be a tightly inflated 120" monster! Now somebody else please calculate the price for the helium…

                Comment

                • zycram
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2024
                  • 408

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Bass Boll
                  The geometric shape with the best volume-to-surface ratio is a sphere - this recommends a beach ball if you want to see something lifting up. But:

                  - The density of air under normal (sea level) pressure and at 20°C is 1.204 kg/m³.
                  - The density of helium under the same conditions is 0.166 kg/m³.
                  This would mean a specific buoyancy of 1.204 - 0.166 = 1.038 kg/m³, but as standard "balloon gas" grade helium is just about 96% pure we may calculate by 1 kg/m³.

                  Question: How big must a beach ball be to contain enough helium to just float in the air?

                  This means the buoyancy F_b must equal the weight F_w.
                  - The buoyancy is given by volume V times the specific buoyancy D_up times the gravitational acceleration g.
                  The weight is the weight of the PVC which more or less resembles the surface:
                  - The weight is given by the surface A times the thickness of the vinyl d times the specific density of PVC D_pvc times the gravitational acceleration g.

                  Now we can formalize:
                  F_b = V · D_up · g
                  F_w = A · d · D_pvc · g

                  F_b = F_w
                  V · D_up · g = A · d · D_pvc · g | The gravitational acceleration g cancels out immediately.
                  V · D_up = A · d · D_pvc | Replace V and A by their radius-based formulas.
                  4/3 π r³ · D_up = 4 π r² · d · D_pvc | Divide by 4 π r².
                  1/3 r · D_up = d · D_pvc | Multiply by 3 and divide by D_up.
                  r = 3 · d · D_pvc/D_up

                  Now we can insert the numbers. The thickness of the PVC shall be assumed 0.25 mm ("10-gauge vinyl"), a reasonable value for big beach balls. (Yes I know, Shosu sell BBB with only 0.18 mm.) The density of soft PVC is about 1.3 g/cm³ or 1300 kg/m³. This yields:

                  r = 3 · 0.00025 m · 1300 kg/m³ / 1 kg/m³ = 3 · 0.00025 m · 1300 = 0.975 m

                  Answer: A standard material beach ball needs to have a diameter of 2 r = 1.95 m or 6 ft 4¾ in. As beach ball sizes are measured uninflated, i.e. along the half circumference, and given in inches, this would be a tightly inflated 120" monster! Now somebody else please calculate the price for the helium…
                  You did not take overinflation into account. If you overinflate your beach ball, it stretches out. On the contrary, the pressure/density of the helium will increase with overinflation. However, If the ball is sturdy enough, it may float when overinflated because the mass of the vinyl does not change.

                  Comment

                  • Bass Boll
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2023
                    • 211

                    #10
                    Originally posted by zycram
                    You did not take overinflation into account...
                    True, but as you mentioned, there are antagonistic effects at play: The higher density with higher pressure vs the increased volume. However, I would think even a tightly inflated beach ball will hardly exceed 5% of overpressure compared to the outside. But there are other factors of uncertainty I did not consider. The experiment could be done on an elevated terrain, the pressure also varies with the weather over time, and the gas densities change with temperature as well. The vinyl could be thinner, and its density could be anywhere in the range of 1.1 to 1.5 g/cm³ depending on the amount and sort of plasticizer applied. And then there are additional weights from the seams and the valve.

                    Thanks for your video! Even considering a wide uncertainty margin the result of my calculation tells me that the ball the guy in the video used was of very thin vinyl. And maybe it's a bit helped by the wind lifting it over the roof? We do not get to see it becoming smaller and smaller and finally disappear in the sky!

                    Comment

                    • zycram
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2024
                      • 408

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Bass Boll

                      True, but as you mentioned, there are antagonistic effects at play: The higher density with higher pressure vs the increased volume. However, I would think even a tightly inflated beach ball will hardly exceed 5% of overpressure compared to the outside. But there are other factors of uncertainty I did not consider. The experiment could be done on an elevated terrain, the pressure also varies with the weather over time, and the gas densities change with temperature as well. The vinyl could be thinner, and its density could be anywhere in the range of 1.1 to 1.5 g/cm³ depending on the amount and sort of plasticizer applied. And then there are additional weights from the seams and the valve.

                      Thanks for your video! Even considering a wide uncertainty margin the result of my calculation tells me that the ball the guy in the video used was of very thin vinyl. And maybe it's a bit helped by the wind lifting it over the roof? We do not get to see it becoming smaller and smaller and finally disappear in the sky!
                      It's about as light as the air outside, maybe a bit lighter. This means that the ball will either stay in place or go up very slowly if you release it.

                      Comment

                      Working...