Sneaky amazon reviews and questions ;)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • John225
    Member
    • Jan 2018
    • 80

    Sneaky amazon reviews and questions ;)

    I got on amazon today browsing like I do from time to time. A few times I'll add a review (mostly just throwing in the fact that the rated size and actual size are different to try and help people avoid confusion and dissapointment)

    So I started reading others reviews and questions. Especially with the 42" and 48". I see reviews about how tough they are. And people asking "what is the best way to pop them". It was fun reading so I started asking similar questions on some of the beach balls that don't have questions like that asked

    I was wondering if anyone here was responsible for any of that or if you thought about it. As a looner it seems like reviews and questions only one of us would post
  • heaviest
    Senior Member
    • Jun 2018
    • 914

    #2
    Here's a feature I miss. Unless I'm just not seeing it, there is no longer a questions section. I used to upvote all the "how much weight will it hold" questions, lol, because that's what I want to know, too!

    But I stopped reviewing things on Amazon when they took down one of my "verified purchase" reviews of a float because they were concerned about its accuracy. Like, on a site with mostly fake reviews they don't think a description of how much weight I got on it without popping it was plausible LOL.

    Yeah, I used to have fun with those.

    I used to answer those "how much weight will it hold" questions with my own anecdotes, too.

    It was fun, so of course they took it away. And, frankly, I buy fewer floats from Amazon because that's an avenue of fun they don't allow anymore. I seriously bought a few items only because I wanted to leave a looner-friendly review.

    Comment

    • heaviest
      Senior Member
      • Jun 2018
      • 914

      #3
      FWIW I told a photographer about my Amazon reviews getting rejected for concern over accuracy, and he suggested uploading photos with my reviews, which I have considered. The girls would have to consent, because I am no longer large enough to put an outrageous amount of weight on an inflatable by myself. They are not rejecting the plan outright. When we took photos on an 18-pocket suntanner we had in mind it was something I could potentially review, except that the ones I have are from Target. So, I ordered some floats from Amazon specifically to review and get a "verified purchase" tag. Photographer is willing. Girls may be willing.

      I'm pretty sure Amazon will reject a review that features an 800 pound woman in a bathing suit, or more likely, yoga pants. We are having a debate here about how much effort is justified to troll Amazon, and whether we'd actually be happy if they let a review stand. We have a one-person float (an Intex suntanner) and a two-person float (a 36-pocket mattress), and a photographer. Now, the courage part...

      I'm told that stock photography sites are open to photography featuring fat women, but not REALLY fat women.

      Comment

      • pawpflower
        Junior Member
        • Aug 2021
        • 1

        #4
        I don't think it is very ethical to question-bait your kink to non-consenting individuals. We have to do better than that. C'mon.

        Comment

        • heaviest
          Senior Member
          • Jun 2018
          • 914

          #5
          Nobody's reading the questions section for beach balls, except for idle entertainment. There are a lot of non-serious questions and reviews on products that don't really warrant questions or reviews. Answers had an helpful/not helpful rating system, and I never saw any inappropriate answers. The questions would just seem weird to someone not in the know.

          FWIW I found one of the reviews for a 42 inch beach ball that was probably left by a looner, and it was marked helpful by 7 people lol. Why would someone bounce on one of these and be disappointed it didn't pop? Someone else reviewed it as a dog toy.
          Last edited by heaviest; 28-03-2025, 05:16.

          Comment

          • pawpflower
            Junior Member
            • Aug 2021
            • 1

            #6
            I meant asking deceptive questions aimed at baiting responses for your own pleasures without consent. But I also think it problematic that looners flood these retail spaces with comments and questions in general. It's kind of like how all the poor women on TikTok or Instagram who have balloon businesses have to warn each other that there are creeps known as "looners" who are trying to solicit free "porn" or whatnot. Most balloon businesses are very much aware of us, have encountered our inappropriate requests, and are not framing our community in a positive light. I'm not saying you are doing this, but I am saying that in bringing the looner phenomenon directly into these spaces we risk much in terms of our reputation, which is already sketchy to an extent. Even I become ashamed by many of the comments in these spaces.

            Comment

            • Guest

              #7
              pawpflower - I am aware of this "behaviour" too, and I am not defending it, in any way. But I also think that this is something common within almost every fetish-community; be it shoes, feet, or anything else. Still, I find this direct "harrassment" of non-looning content creators very awkward, to say the least. I already cringe when I read the comments at most looner-videos, so seeing "normal" people exposed to this, is even worse.

              Comment

              • heaviest
                Senior Member
                • Jun 2018
                • 914

                #8
                Originally posted by pawpflower
                I meant asking deceptive questions aimed at baiting responses for your own pleasures without consent. But I also think it problematic that looners flood these retail spaces with comments and questions in general. It's kind of like how all the poor women on TikTok or Instagram who have balloon businesses have to warn each other that there are creeps known as "looners" who are trying to solicit free "porn" or whatnot.
                If people are asking balloon sellers for photos, that is out of line.

                If people are asking how to pop beach balls, that's not harassment, but it is weird, and it's not a legit discussion of the product outside a forum like this one.

                But these are products with non-obvious uses and the people who buy them for that purpose are legit customers, and probably a significant part of the business. As long as they keep their reviews free of adult discussion and don't solicit response from the unwilling, I don't see the problem. "It'll float 600 pounds without bursting. Only half that with any stability, but these things are way sturdier than you'd think." answers the question honestly, potentially helpfully.

                "I was unable to pop it by bouncing on it"? I would consider it just funny noise. Like the one that reviewed it as a dog toy. Not useful to people buying it as a pool toy, but then again, those people aren't reading the reviews beyond the rating and the ones flagged most helpful.

                I went looking for the beach ball one because you said it was there to be found and you gave enough info to find it. But I've been buying floats on Amazon forever and reading teh reviews and questions, and before you mentioned it I'd never seen an obvious looner contribution.

                EDIT:

                Oh, good lord lol. I went and looked at an inflatable in my recent browsing history and found a review praising a chair for its fetish potential on the first item I checked. Literally, used the word fetish, and it's the third review on the page. Come on people, keep it classy.

                That review has been up there for months, though, and not taken down.
                Last edited by heaviest; 28-01-2026, 03:45.

                Comment

                • heaviest
                  Senior Member
                  • Jun 2018
                  • 914

                  #9
                  One...

                  FWIW the review I did that was taken down for being "of questionable accuracy" or whatever was of an inflatable butterfly float. It was intended for one person, but it was really large. Between me and my ex we weighed about 1000 pounds and we could both lay on it, and I said so, though I think I said "we are both extremely large" and didn't put a number to it.

                  I didn't do that just for the fun of it. Almost all inflatables have reviews of "it didn't hold air more than a day", or "it didn't even hold up to my 90 pound daughter". I've had my fair share of duds, but my regular experience with inflatables is that they hold a ridiculous amount of weight, and I'd like to counter the common perception that they aren't up to holding the weight of adults. And yeah, I want people to know they'll take the weight of an adult couple. Even if they'll underestimate what I mean by "extremely large", I've given them reason to believe adults can use these things. Large adults. TWO large adults.

                  I also described what it was like on the water. Perfectly usable for one extremely large adult, if a bit difficult to get on and stay on. On the water, though, just one. But two out of water.

                  Permission granted. Buy this thing even if you're extremely large.

                  I do this at pools, too. When I use the inflatables, other adults, even large adults, become less bashful about using them.

                  Two...

                  I know a photographer who does "stock photography", and he has said that he can post pictures of fat women, but photos of extremely fat women get taken down as "inappropriate". This pisses off the women in my life.

                  Now, suppose my Amazon review had a photo. "Of questionable accuracy", my ass. But would a review that included a picture of an extremely fat woman be considered inappropriate? We're not fat activists, but we'd really like to know.

                  Comment

                  • heaviest
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2018
                    • 914

                    #10
                    Originally posted by heaviest
                    Now, suppose my Amazon review had a photo. ... But would a review that included a picture of an extremely fat woman be considered inappropriate?
                    We tested it. I submitted a review of an Intex 18-pocket suntanner, with a photo of an extremely large lady on it. It was rejected, but the thing is they don't tell you why. We've read the guidelines and some online discussion, and we were very careful to follow all the rules, but one thing we cannot control for is the product is supposed to be clearly visible and identifiable, but not have logos or packaging, and the product isn't clearly visible in our photo because the woman on it is way bigger than the mattress. It's pretty clear from the pillow that she is on a silver suntanner, but there isn't much else of the mattress visible.

                    She was wearing yoga shorts and shirt, and only her arms, calves and feet were bare, and her head was turned away from the camera (you're not supposed to have faces, either). We don't have a lot of summer poolside photos that are as safe as that one to try again. We'll revisit this in the summer, maybe with a larger float.

                    The girls want to try with a living room photo, but I cannot select an item I ordered a long time ago for review, so reviewing the Paradise Mat is right out, because it's no longer available. I'd have to order a Swimline 36-pocket to do that one, but it's still available. So is the French Fry float. And we are going to try to get a photo on the 18-pocket that shows more of the mattress.
                    Last edited by heaviest; 29-01-2026, 09:01.

                    Comment

                    • heaviest
                      Senior Member
                      • Jun 2018
                      • 914

                      #11
                      I have my next test image ready to accompany a review. It is 605-pound "Shorts Girl" and 275-pound "Emo Girl" laying on a double-wide 36-pocket air mattress at the side of the pool. It was taken on a warm day, but their wearing bathing suits was just for photography. The water is way too cold for swimming. And I'll have to buy one of these mattresses before I can review it as a "verified purchaser", since it's been a long time since I bought one.

                      For review rejection purposes, these women are wider than the mattress, but only in the hips and legs. There is enough of the mattress showing that it is clearly the product being reviewed. They can't realistically reject it because of that.

                      Shorts Girl's legs are each bigger than her waist, and she's got an extremely large butt. You'd be completely rational questioning if this image was AI generated. Possibly they could reject it thinking it was AI. An image of a woman shaped like that is also unavoidably sexual, no matter what she's wearing, and in the image she's wearing a full-coverage bikini, more like gym shorts, but there's no avoiding that they fit her funny, so it's unavoidably a sexy picture. They could reject it for that.

                      You don't really appreciate how big she is unless she's next to someone. Next to conventionally fat Emo Girl, Shorts Girl looks gigantic. I don't know how normal people see wild differences in size, but to those attracted to large women, a size difference alone is sexy.

                      But there is nothing in the image that is outside the norm for a family-friendly poolside photo, other than the size of one of the women, which in all fairness, shouldn't be considered obscene. She's wearing a full-coverage bikini.

                      While we were at it, we also got photos of 820-pound "Gym Girl" laying on the mattress with Emo Girl. In that one it could be argued it is unclear the photo is of the reviewed product. The difference between 605 and 820 pounds is way more even than you'd think, and there isn't much of the mattress showing, and I really wanted more butts-up photos, for the size comparison. By the time we got around to trying Gym Girl on her side, to make more room on the mattress, the mattress popped. We were being careful, but the mattress was very fully inflated for the photography. A pop is still unexpected. We would have had to include that in the review had we used that photo lol.

                      "We did pop this mattress, but it held for a long time before it popped," would still be a five-star review!

                      Comment

                      Working...