Balloon Math

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • LeeRider
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2014
    • 154

    #16
    Re: Balloon Math

    Originally posted by JR Looner
    That was the largest I was able to make a GL700. I think I inflated it once before this picture was taken. It's almost 9.5 feet long, given that the wood flooring was actually installed above the original level of the carpet by almost 4 inches.
    you should try blowing up a Tilly Worker too! they are FUN! you would probably get it to at least that length and they are a good ride!

    Comment

    • JR Looner
      Member
      • May 2015
      • 98

      #17
      Re: Balloon Math

      I have some Tilly Workers still, from before they stopped making them. Green, Blue and Purple ones without the stripes on them. The ones with the stripes on them are pre-inflated, and honestly I prefer the striped Tilly Workers over the non-striped ones. The Tilly Workers I still have are rather old, and I don't want to inflate them cuz they might pop pre-maturely.

      Comment

      • LeeRider
        Senior Member
        • Nov 2014
        • 154

        #18
        Re: Balloon Math

        Originally posted by JR Looner
        I have some Tilly Workers still, from before they stopped making them. Green, Blue and Purple ones without the stripes on them. The ones with the stripes on them are pre-inflated, and honestly I prefer the striped Tilly Workers over the non-striped ones. The Tilly Workers I still have are rather old, and I don't want to inflate them cuz they might pop pre-maturely.
        Probably ok if you stored em somewhere cool and away from light.

        There is a right and wrong way to blow up Tilly Workers and it is usually best not to risk overinflation although even regular inflation to full size can be rather alarming!

        Apparently the ones with stripes are preinflated in the factory to paint the stripes on so any with manufacturing defects would have burst in the factory so they are usually though to be more reliable.

        Comment

        • wildheart
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2015
          • 872

          #19
          Re: Balloon Math

          I used a more scientific method (using water displacement) and got a result of 2.3 litres. I'm a guy. (6ft though quite skinny). Using a balloon isn't the most accurate way to do it.
          How big will it go? Only one way to find out...
          My website: loonerstories.weebly.com

          Comment

          • SweetBouncer
            Senior Member
            • Mar 2020
            • 218

            #20
            Re: Balloon Math

            Pretty interesting.But, in a matter of geometry, the balloon could be divided in three forms: a sphere for the body, a truncated cone for the intersection between the neck and the body, and a cylinder for the neck. I suposse that in a GL you could swap the sphere for another cylinder.

            All thats lef it's apply the same method with the equations for the volumes of those three solids.
            Being the volume the same the only thing left should be the radius for the truncated cone and the cylinder

            Hypothetically this could be apply to any balloon, you just need to divide it in it's basic geometry forms.

            I've managed to put it somehow together:
            V=(4/3 × π x r'^3) + (π x h x (R^2 x r^2 + R × r)/3) + (π x r^2 x h')
            h and h' are basically the length of the inflated neck (h') and the intersection (h)
            r' is the radius of the sphere, r is the radius of the cylinder and the little base of the truncated cone, and R is the radius of the big base.
            Last edited by SweetBouncer; 27-04-2020, 00:04.

            Comment

            • TheGrimLooner
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2017
              • 156

              #21
              Re: Balloon Math

              Guys guys guys guys guys.

              I have waited over 9000 years for this topic to come up.
              I did not read the replies carefully because I just want to theorize at this stage. But I think a balloon being blown up to pop could be mathematically modeled.


              Firstly, I think most of us understand that there may be a linear relationship between between volume and pressure. And that there is a linear relationship of elasticity. Hello Young's modulus for tensile strength. That's what you get when you calculate stress divided by strain.
              Stress = force/area (like pressure)
              Strain = change in length/initial length (like the volume change)

              For blowing up a balloon, the stress/strain relationship if not linear all the way.
              First, you need to put enough air to make the balloon stretch. The bigger the balloon, the more air you need to make the latex start to stretch.

              Then towards the end, the latex cannot stretch any further, and thus the stress/strain relationship changes. The pressure starts to increase massively with minimal volume change before pop. The popping pressure would depend on the strength of the balloon.

              Other contributing factors

              Compliance and elasticity of the material:
              The Young's modulus (the elasticity) will differ between balloons. Some balloons will also be more compliant - that means they stretch with less force. Less steep stress/strain curve. Balloons are more compliant that say, a steel rod.


              The shape:
              I don't know how to account for this, but it's an extra spanner in the works and probably adds to the variability. Especially for where the fracture point will occur.

              Types of deformation
              Elastic - return to original shape
              Plastic - stretches, but does not return to original shape
              Fracture - pop!

              If I inflate then deflate a balloon partially, I see plastic and elastic deformation occurring at the same time. Just in the begining, it's more elastic, before fracture, it's more plastic.

              All you nerds can graph the stress/strain relationship, if you are able to control the volume input as the independent variable (keep other variables constant to minimize confound). Then measure the volume change. Engineers and material scientists on here can probably correct me on what I'm saying, so by nerds I mean those who are interested, but not experienced in the area.

              Data to also record are the balloon brand, batch and the rated size. If you can measure the size of the balloon at atmospheric pressure but full volume, it will give you the initial volume before stretch. Probably need pressure gauge. Then, you could work out the young's modulus per balloon type, as well as the strength. Furthermore, you could work out the reliability of balloons by working out the variability when you do repeats of the same balloon type, and calculating the standard deviation. You might find some brands strengths are consistent, while others are not.

              Video of the stress/strain curve in a balloon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKhi-HVMaYo

              Edit: Gas compression
              How could I forget. As srob2 mentions, gas is compressible. Unlike liquid. So that means volume and pressure will not be linearly proportional I believe. I subconsciously waved that away considering that the stress/strain curve is also not linear towards capacity. The end results is having to pump in more breathes (pressure) towards the end for a smaller change in volume.

              Now okay lungs
              Yeah, lung function is another interesting topic. It is measured with spectrometry. Something like this is better used to measure your lung capacity, as a piston type system keeps the relationship between volume and pressure more linear and reliable, than how many breaths to pop a balloon.
              Last edited by TheGrimLooner; 28-04-2020, 10:19.

              Comment

              • srob2
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2017
                • 552

                #22
                Re: Balloon Math

                Gas does compress, but not in an ordinary balloon. Suppose it takes 10 breaths on average to pop a small, very tight balloon. Until breath 9, you won't feel much pressure. Now if you have a really strong balloon, it might not pop until 16+ breaths. But this isn't you putting your full lung capacity of air into the balloon, these last few breaths, very little air goes in, you are just stretching and pushing air in to weaken the latex.

                Comment

                • b0f0s0f
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2016
                  • 329

                  #23
                  Re: Balloon Math

                  The biggest challenge to me seems to be estimating the thickness of the balloon's walls. The thickness isn't uniform, but it's not clear to what degree. We all know they're thicker at the drip point at least, but I'm sure there's a relatively significant difference between the thickness at all points along its length. Even thought the differences are probably small in absolute terms, when we're dealing with something like this they probably make a big difference.

                  I'm a physicist so in theory I have the tools to address this fairly rigorously (well, as rigorous as we physicists are capable of, Taylor series expansions and all), but I would probably need to do some experiments which I'm not really at liberty to do given my living situation. I'm also not a materials guy (too bad balloons aren't subatomic particles) so I'm not exactly experienced in this subfield but hey, our job is basically to figure shit out on the fly. We need to know things like internal pressure vs. balloon size during inflation to figure out the stress and strain, and I'm not equipped to figure this out. I wonder if the engineers among us would be more helpful, maybe someone can whip up a model in ANSYS or something.

                  DrGrelka (who runs the Inflation Laboratory clip store) seems like he actually takes data in his videos, I wonder if anyone could snag his whole dataset and we could start curve fitting. That would be a great place to start.

                  Comment

                  • srob2
                    Senior Member
                    • Dec 2017
                    • 552

                    #24
                    Re: Balloon Math

                    Connect a hose to a pump, put a balloon on the hose, put the hose on a kitchen scale. Run the pump until the balloon pops. If air is compressed, the balloon will get heavier. I haven't actually tried this, but doubt the weight changes much.

                    Comment

                    • b0f0s0f
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2016
                      • 329

                      #25
                      Re: Balloon Math

                      The air definitely gets compressed to some extent, the rubber constantly tends towards contracting, and the only thing that keeps it from doing so is the air pressure increasing to form an equilibrium where the latex is tight. The force required to push outwards on the balloon to keep it inflated is going to be opposed by a force squeezing the air inside, so it really needs to be measured to see the magnitude of the force being supported by the material.

                      Comment

                      • SweetBouncer
                        Senior Member
                        • Mar 2020
                        • 218

                        #26
                        Re: Balloon Math

                        Come on we are almost there, this just need a little push.

                        Comment

                        • b0f0s0f
                          Senior Member
                          • Nov 2016
                          • 329

                          #27
                          Re: Balloon Math

                          We sort of need to define what we're aiming for in order to try to model it. Estimating when a balloon will pop, for instance, is nearly impossible to figure a priori; statistical models and data are needed. A lot of this comes down to materials stuff which is not easy to approximate.

                          In the meantime, people viewing this thread may be interested to read this comment I wrote elsewhere about how balloons burst in between breaths while doing a b2p:
                          Originally posted by srob2
                          I am surprised how often this happens, even with big breaths and little time between them. It is almost like it takes the balloon 10 seconds to stretch to the size of the last breath.
                          My reply:
                          Originally posted by b0f0s0f
                          That is actually a very interesting point. From a statistical mechanics standpoint, elastic materials can be thought of as piled up chains of molecules. Molecules are all jiggling around due to heat, which keeps the chains piled up. Stretching the rubber forces the chains to straighten out, which takes energy. The reason why balloons feel cold when you deflate them is because instead of everything just vibrating in place, the motion is actually "stolen" to move the chains back towards the high entropy, coiled up state. This absorption of heat also means there is less thermal motion available to jiggle the chains to help them contract and pile back up, which is why heating a freshly deflated balloon causes it to further contract, since the heat of your hands is taken to further jiggle the chains.

                          The reason I find the quote interesting is because this process probably follows a sort of exponential trajectory, where when you blow into the balloon, most of the expansion happens right away as the "low hanging fruit" slack is taken up, but over the next half second or two, the molecules continue straightening as the system untangles itself a bit further. This would explain the exact mechanism through which a balloon pops spontaneously when edged to maximum inflation; as the tangled molecules continue to slowly work their kinks out and become straighter, the stress is distributed around until finally some spot takes on juuust too much of the stress, leading to a catastrophic failure.

                          Comment

                          • srob2
                            Senior Member
                            • Dec 2017
                            • 552

                            #28
                            Re: Balloon Math

                            I am surprised how much more air a larger balloon takes. I can burst a 5" balloon in 1 breath, if I have a tube, but sometimes I can't blow hard enough. A 9" balloon isn't fun to blow, just a few breaths and it is ready to pop. 12"-14" are the most fun for me, as each breath is exciting and they take a lot more. Anything larger than 16" and I am almost bored blowing until it is almost full.

                            Comment

                            • b0f0s0f
                              Senior Member
                              • Nov 2016
                              • 329

                              #29
                              Re: Balloon Math

                              Yup, most of the questions in this sub can be explained by the fact that balloons are more or less spherical, and the volume of a sphere is proportional to the cube of the radius, so a balloon that's twice as wide has eight times more volume. Things get a little tricky to approximate when you start considering the volume of the neck and stuff, but it's close enough to show why a 5" balloon takes 1 breath and a 12" takes about 8.

                              Comment

                              Working...