I thought I'd start a "tier-list" of balloons we can discuss, starting with "medium-sized" balloons.
These are my ratings of all the 15"-19" balloons I've tried, which I consider "medium-size." I'm mostly considering shape (e.g. how well they neck), reliability, color, and to a lesser extent, price and availability. If the differences varies wildly between color types, I'll rank them separately.
My tiers are loosely based on the following criteria:
S-tier = Truly special that sets them apart from other balloons. They're actually so good I almost don't even want to use them.
A-tier = A balloon I will regularly buy again
B-tier = Still good, but I'd rather just buy A-tiers over them
C-tier = Wouldn't buy again
D-tier = Something truly bad
I should note that aside from a few I've done on a pump, I have never blown to popped any of these, so this is coming from a semi-popper who doesn't do blow to pops. But if anyone has blown to popped any of these or wants to try, definitely leave a comment.
Anyway, here we go.
Globos Payaso 15" (Standard Assorted Colors)
B-tier
These are "paddle" shaped balloons that are like a cross between a round and "jellybean" balloon. They're kind of cool, but are just too small for me. Also, good luck finding any.
Globos Payaso 16" (Crystal Red)
B-tier
They're okay, but they just get too small. I also don't like the way they smell. And again, good luck finding any.
Qualatex 16" (Jewel Teal)
C-tier
These have a great color, however they're too small, have hardly any neck, and the ones I did try to neck popped.
But of course, Qualatex is defunct, so these aren't available anymore. The only way I got some was I got a balloon store's last pack of them, and what sucks is they charged me like a dollar per balloon, but after they rung me up, they said they never planned on selling them because Qualatex went out of business. If I would have known that, I would have asked for a discount.
Tuftex 17" (Standards and Crystals)
A-tier
I consider these the "gold standard", and I've used these more than any other balloon. They have a great shape, can neck pretty well (especially if you pre-inflate it), have a vibrant color, and aside from one I tried to aggressively pre-neck, I have never had one spontaneously pop. They're also relatively inexpensive for their size, and they're one of the last remaining medium-sized balloons that are available in crystal colors.
Now I do know people say Tuftex balloons have a short shelf life, however I have some I bought over a year ago that have yet to go bad. But given these are pretty inexpensive for how many you get, I'd argue you get what you pay for.
Funsational 17" (Standard Assortment)
A-Tier
These are based on the original design and formula of BSA's 17" balloons, which were "thicker" than "normal" balloons, were very round, and could get huge necks, and these definitely live up to these characteristics. In fact, if you inflate the neck of these balloons first and continue to blow up the "bulb", the air in the neck won't "retract" into the bulb like it will on most other balloons, which I call "blowing up a balloon backwards", so you can fully neck these without overinflating them.
However, despite supposedly being "thicker" than "normal" balloons, these seem to be just as thick if not thinner than Tuftex 17"s, the neck length varies between colors, and I've had at least one spontaneously pop. And given these are sold in the same type of standard assortments as Tuftex 17"s are, and Tuftex took over Pioneer's factories when they went defunct, I think these are made by Tuftex, but with a little less quality control. However, I'm rating them A-tier because they have an amazing shape, can neck extremely well, and have a cool "story" behind them.
And speaking of that story....
BSA 17" (Radiant Gold)
S-Tier
I got balloons.online's second to last pack, and I am very sad these have been discontinued. While I can't quite do a direct comparison between these and the Funsational 17"s because these are Pearls and thus much thicker (Funsational does make 17"s in Gold that I'm eager to try, which I will when I run low on these), I can say these are pretty much the same as the Funsational 17"s, albeit they have a thinner neck. What's crazy though is I bought these well over a year ago, and they have yet to go bad, and I've never had one spontaneously pop.
I really wish I got to experience these in crystal colors, as these would have been one of my favorite medium-sized balloons.
Belbal 17's (Standard Assortment)
B-tier
These behave sort of like Tuftex 17"s, but are not fluted, are slightly softer, and have a neck that "blends in" with the bulb better than it does on a TT17", which can get quite long. However, the "standard" colors are very "dull" compared to TT17"s, which are more "shiny." I've had a few spontaneously pop while sitting around, so their reliability isn't up there. Still, they're a good alternative to Tuftex 17"s, albeit a little more expensive.
Belbal 17" Soap Crystals
S-tier
These are amazing. The colors are gorgeous, and the necks can get huge. Massive step above the standard Belbal 17"s. The only downside is they're not available in assortments, so I have way too many because I wanted to try all the colors.
Walmart/Hobby Lobby 17"s/18"s (Standard Colors)
S-tier
I call these the "Universal Chinese Medium-Sized Balloons" in that they're sold under multiple obscure brands you can find online and in some retail stores, but they all have the same characteristics in that they have a distinct "smell" that I describe as smelling like "sawdust", they look very big when uninflated, are somewhat thin, inflate rather round, but get tear-dropped shaped and grow a sizable (wide) neck when overinflated.
While the ones you can buy on Amazon are really hit and miss in quality, the ones I'm ranking used to be sold at Walmart as 17"s, but are now sold at Hobby Lobby as 18"s. However, these could be sold as 20" because they don't even begin to get tight or grow a neck until they get to that size, and don't enter the "danger zone" until they get to around 24", and when they do, they get a huge neck. So these by far get bigger than their rated size when compared to any other balloon, and look great when overinflated. In fact, these are what I used to (partially) get over my fear of balloons, and when I finally got some "decorator quality" balloons like Tuftex 17"s, I was so confused why they were getting so tight compared to these, and it's because I later realized these should be sold as 20". Also, they have the brightest colors of any balloon I've tried. The reds look like the paint on a Ferrari. And because you can buy these in a store, they're some of the most accessible "medium-sized" balloons. Not to mention these make more of a "poof" than a sharp "bang" when they pop, so are thus not as loud as other balloons, which may be good for non-poppers. So these are awesome.
Kalisan 18" (Standard Red, Green, and Black)
A+-tier
These may be the only medium-sized balloons that are literally designed for the neck to bulge out, as once they get to about 17", you can literally just pull on the neck and it will inflate all the way, with no pre-necking required. However, standard colors aren't available in assortments, and the "standard" colors I've tried (red and green) were dull-looking and had "splotches", so they don't have the greatest colors, which is why I'm not giving them a full S-tier. But if Kalisan still made 18" crystals, they would be S+-tier, and they'd probably be the only medium-sized balloons I'd buy.
Kalisan 18" (Macaron Assortment)
C-tier
These didn't seem to inflate as big as the standards, and the colors were even more dull.
Cattex 18" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These have a very "archetypal" balloon shape in that they're very "tear drop"-shaped, and the latex seems to be somehow "thin" but "hard" at the same time. I describe it like an "egg shell." However, I had quite a few spontaneous pops with these, so they're not super reliable, and while they can get a pretty big neck, they'll likely pop well before you get it to full size.
Cattex 18" (Crystals)
D-tier
While these look amazing, they are the most unreliable medium-sized balloon I've ever tried. I had maybe 1 in 5 spontaneously pop while or shortly after inflating them. In fact, these look identical to Belbal 17"s, so I suspect Cattex may have taken an old or defective batch of Belbal 17"s and rebranded them as their own.
Sempertex 18" (Standard Black)
A-tier
These are very "pear" shaped in that they have a short, wide neck, and just like the BSA and Funsational 17"s, you can inflate the neck first and it won't retract into the bulb, so you can inflate these with a neck without overinflating them.
"Michaels" 18" (Hot Pink and Dark Green)
A-tier
These are the 18" balloons Michael's sells, making them another easy to obtain "medium-sized" balloon. They're similar in shape to the "Universal Chinese Medium-Sized Balloons", but they're thicker, and begin to get tight and neck at their rated size. In fact, they actually have a very similar size and shape to the Sempertex 18"s in that they're "pear"-shaped, and if you inflate the neck first, the neck will stay inflated. The only downside is the colors look a little "splotchy." But I'm giving them A-tier due to their ease of access. They make a great "impulse purchase."
Balloonia 18" (Standard Red)
C-tier
These are very tear-drop shaped and have a very smooth texture, but what knocks them to a C-tier is they are the most expensive "decorator quality" medium size balloons you can get, costing almost $1/each, which is in no way worth it.
Celetex 18" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These remind me of the Cattex 18"s. Very tear-drop shaped, and feel like an "egg shell." But what's odd about these is they vary in shape and quality depending on the color. The light blues can get pretty long necks, while the whites and pinks barely neck and get extremely tight at their rated size. The lime green ones on the other hand seem to get a very wide neck that "naturally" forms when they reach their rated size, and are still somewhat squishy at that size. However, I had a few spontaneous pop with them (including a lime green one that was still squishy), so these aren't very reliable.
Prolatex 18" (Black)
C-tier
These have a very "archetypal" balloon shape, but begin to neck and get tight around 16", so I'm not confident in their ability to get to 18". But they are quite cheap.
Prima 19" (Garnet)
B-tier
While they get quite tight before their rated size, these neck pretty easily if you inflate the neck first. Also, despite the color being "standard", it's almost crystal, so these look really nice. Not to mention they're quite cheap.
Gemar 19" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These are very round, have hardly any neck, and barely get to their rated size.
Cattex 19" (Standard Assortment and Black)
B-tier
These are the "oddest" looking medium-sized balloons. The best way I can describe them is they're "seashell-shaped" in that the "top" portion of the bulb is round, but the "bottom" portion is like a very wide "parabola." Despite this, they can get an unusually long neck for how round they are. They're also very "fluted" to the point they look like a punchball, so they're not the best-looking balloons. Still, they're pretty cool in terms of their novelty. However, good luck finding any.
Anyway, let me know how you'd rank these brands.
These are my ratings of all the 15"-19" balloons I've tried, which I consider "medium-size." I'm mostly considering shape (e.g. how well they neck), reliability, color, and to a lesser extent, price and availability. If the differences varies wildly between color types, I'll rank them separately.
My tiers are loosely based on the following criteria:
S-tier = Truly special that sets them apart from other balloons. They're actually so good I almost don't even want to use them.
A-tier = A balloon I will regularly buy again
B-tier = Still good, but I'd rather just buy A-tiers over them
C-tier = Wouldn't buy again
D-tier = Something truly bad
I should note that aside from a few I've done on a pump, I have never blown to popped any of these, so this is coming from a semi-popper who doesn't do blow to pops. But if anyone has blown to popped any of these or wants to try, definitely leave a comment.
Anyway, here we go.
Globos Payaso 15" (Standard Assorted Colors)
B-tier
These are "paddle" shaped balloons that are like a cross between a round and "jellybean" balloon. They're kind of cool, but are just too small for me. Also, good luck finding any.
Globos Payaso 16" (Crystal Red)
B-tier
They're okay, but they just get too small. I also don't like the way they smell. And again, good luck finding any.
Qualatex 16" (Jewel Teal)
C-tier
These have a great color, however they're too small, have hardly any neck, and the ones I did try to neck popped.
But of course, Qualatex is defunct, so these aren't available anymore. The only way I got some was I got a balloon store's last pack of them, and what sucks is they charged me like a dollar per balloon, but after they rung me up, they said they never planned on selling them because Qualatex went out of business. If I would have known that, I would have asked for a discount.
Tuftex 17" (Standards and Crystals)
A-tier
I consider these the "gold standard", and I've used these more than any other balloon. They have a great shape, can neck pretty well (especially if you pre-inflate it), have a vibrant color, and aside from one I tried to aggressively pre-neck, I have never had one spontaneously pop. They're also relatively inexpensive for their size, and they're one of the last remaining medium-sized balloons that are available in crystal colors.
Now I do know people say Tuftex balloons have a short shelf life, however I have some I bought over a year ago that have yet to go bad. But given these are pretty inexpensive for how many you get, I'd argue you get what you pay for.
Funsational 17" (Standard Assortment)
A-Tier
These are based on the original design and formula of BSA's 17" balloons, which were "thicker" than "normal" balloons, were very round, and could get huge necks, and these definitely live up to these characteristics. In fact, if you inflate the neck of these balloons first and continue to blow up the "bulb", the air in the neck won't "retract" into the bulb like it will on most other balloons, which I call "blowing up a balloon backwards", so you can fully neck these without overinflating them.
However, despite supposedly being "thicker" than "normal" balloons, these seem to be just as thick if not thinner than Tuftex 17"s, the neck length varies between colors, and I've had at least one spontaneously pop. And given these are sold in the same type of standard assortments as Tuftex 17"s are, and Tuftex took over Pioneer's factories when they went defunct, I think these are made by Tuftex, but with a little less quality control. However, I'm rating them A-tier because they have an amazing shape, can neck extremely well, and have a cool "story" behind them.
And speaking of that story....
BSA 17" (Radiant Gold)
S-Tier
I got balloons.online's second to last pack, and I am very sad these have been discontinued. While I can't quite do a direct comparison between these and the Funsational 17"s because these are Pearls and thus much thicker (Funsational does make 17"s in Gold that I'm eager to try, which I will when I run low on these), I can say these are pretty much the same as the Funsational 17"s, albeit they have a thinner neck. What's crazy though is I bought these well over a year ago, and they have yet to go bad, and I've never had one spontaneously pop.
I really wish I got to experience these in crystal colors, as these would have been one of my favorite medium-sized balloons.
Belbal 17's (Standard Assortment)
B-tier
These behave sort of like Tuftex 17"s, but are not fluted, are slightly softer, and have a neck that "blends in" with the bulb better than it does on a TT17", which can get quite long. However, the "standard" colors are very "dull" compared to TT17"s, which are more "shiny." I've had a few spontaneously pop while sitting around, so their reliability isn't up there. Still, they're a good alternative to Tuftex 17"s, albeit a little more expensive.
Belbal 17" Soap Crystals
S-tier
These are amazing. The colors are gorgeous, and the necks can get huge. Massive step above the standard Belbal 17"s. The only downside is they're not available in assortments, so I have way too many because I wanted to try all the colors.
Walmart/Hobby Lobby 17"s/18"s (Standard Colors)
S-tier
I call these the "Universal Chinese Medium-Sized Balloons" in that they're sold under multiple obscure brands you can find online and in some retail stores, but they all have the same characteristics in that they have a distinct "smell" that I describe as smelling like "sawdust", they look very big when uninflated, are somewhat thin, inflate rather round, but get tear-dropped shaped and grow a sizable (wide) neck when overinflated.
While the ones you can buy on Amazon are really hit and miss in quality, the ones I'm ranking used to be sold at Walmart as 17"s, but are now sold at Hobby Lobby as 18"s. However, these could be sold as 20" because they don't even begin to get tight or grow a neck until they get to that size, and don't enter the "danger zone" until they get to around 24", and when they do, they get a huge neck. So these by far get bigger than their rated size when compared to any other balloon, and look great when overinflated. In fact, these are what I used to (partially) get over my fear of balloons, and when I finally got some "decorator quality" balloons like Tuftex 17"s, I was so confused why they were getting so tight compared to these, and it's because I later realized these should be sold as 20". Also, they have the brightest colors of any balloon I've tried. The reds look like the paint on a Ferrari. And because you can buy these in a store, they're some of the most accessible "medium-sized" balloons. Not to mention these make more of a "poof" than a sharp "bang" when they pop, so are thus not as loud as other balloons, which may be good for non-poppers. So these are awesome.
Kalisan 18" (Standard Red, Green, and Black)
A+-tier
These may be the only medium-sized balloons that are literally designed for the neck to bulge out, as once they get to about 17", you can literally just pull on the neck and it will inflate all the way, with no pre-necking required. However, standard colors aren't available in assortments, and the "standard" colors I've tried (red and green) were dull-looking and had "splotches", so they don't have the greatest colors, which is why I'm not giving them a full S-tier. But if Kalisan still made 18" crystals, they would be S+-tier, and they'd probably be the only medium-sized balloons I'd buy.
Kalisan 18" (Macaron Assortment)
C-tier
These didn't seem to inflate as big as the standards, and the colors were even more dull.
Cattex 18" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These have a very "archetypal" balloon shape in that they're very "tear drop"-shaped, and the latex seems to be somehow "thin" but "hard" at the same time. I describe it like an "egg shell." However, I had quite a few spontaneous pops with these, so they're not super reliable, and while they can get a pretty big neck, they'll likely pop well before you get it to full size.
Cattex 18" (Crystals)
D-tier
While these look amazing, they are the most unreliable medium-sized balloon I've ever tried. I had maybe 1 in 5 spontaneously pop while or shortly after inflating them. In fact, these look identical to Belbal 17"s, so I suspect Cattex may have taken an old or defective batch of Belbal 17"s and rebranded them as their own.
Sempertex 18" (Standard Black)
A-tier
These are very "pear" shaped in that they have a short, wide neck, and just like the BSA and Funsational 17"s, you can inflate the neck first and it won't retract into the bulb, so you can inflate these with a neck without overinflating them.
"Michaels" 18" (Hot Pink and Dark Green)
A-tier
These are the 18" balloons Michael's sells, making them another easy to obtain "medium-sized" balloon. They're similar in shape to the "Universal Chinese Medium-Sized Balloons", but they're thicker, and begin to get tight and neck at their rated size. In fact, they actually have a very similar size and shape to the Sempertex 18"s in that they're "pear"-shaped, and if you inflate the neck first, the neck will stay inflated. The only downside is the colors look a little "splotchy." But I'm giving them A-tier due to their ease of access. They make a great "impulse purchase."
Balloonia 18" (Standard Red)
C-tier
These are very tear-drop shaped and have a very smooth texture, but what knocks them to a C-tier is they are the most expensive "decorator quality" medium size balloons you can get, costing almost $1/each, which is in no way worth it.
Celetex 18" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These remind me of the Cattex 18"s. Very tear-drop shaped, and feel like an "egg shell." But what's odd about these is they vary in shape and quality depending on the color. The light blues can get pretty long necks, while the whites and pinks barely neck and get extremely tight at their rated size. The lime green ones on the other hand seem to get a very wide neck that "naturally" forms when they reach their rated size, and are still somewhat squishy at that size. However, I had a few spontaneous pop with them (including a lime green one that was still squishy), so these aren't very reliable.
Prolatex 18" (Black)
C-tier
These have a very "archetypal" balloon shape, but begin to neck and get tight around 16", so I'm not confident in their ability to get to 18". But they are quite cheap.
Prima 19" (Garnet)
B-tier
While they get quite tight before their rated size, these neck pretty easily if you inflate the neck first. Also, despite the color being "standard", it's almost crystal, so these look really nice. Not to mention they're quite cheap.
Gemar 19" (Standard Assortment)
C-tier
These are very round, have hardly any neck, and barely get to their rated size.
Cattex 19" (Standard Assortment and Black)
B-tier
These are the "oddest" looking medium-sized balloons. The best way I can describe them is they're "seashell-shaped" in that the "top" portion of the bulb is round, but the "bottom" portion is like a very wide "parabola." Despite this, they can get an unusually long neck for how round they are. They're also very "fluted" to the point they look like a punchball, so they're not the best-looking balloons. Still, they're pretty cool in terms of their novelty. However, good luck finding any.
Anyway, let me know how you'd rank these brands.
Comment