Fake wardrobe as silent popping chamber

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TermicznySufit
    Junior Member
    • Feb 2018
    • 4

    Fake wardrobe as silent popping chamber

    I've read Kitten's post about her fort from bed mattresses which got me thinking about building fake warderobe for my apartment.
    Right now I'm living in old commie block, i barelly can hear my neighbours but b2p are big no no.
    So i was thinking of using a thick 18-20mm MDF x2 for walls, mineral wool 5-7cm and butyl pads for making sort of a chamber to muffle popping sound
    Making such a thing is not a problem for Me, I was thinking about making it about 2m long/high and 1m wide inside but my question is if anyone tried using mineral woll for such application?, I know audiophiles are using woll for sound deadening but I can't find reliable results anywhere.
    If i could muffle 50-75% of sound i will be satisfied.
    Anyone experimented with such a concept?
  • Not2big
    Member
    • May 2024
    • 60

    #2
    I have not, but I hope it works out for you.

    Comment

    • Guest

      #3
      Foam is not soundproofing. It is only really useful for reducing echoes/reflections of relatively high frequency sounds.

      A lot of what laypeople mistake for soundproofing, like the panels filled with rockwool, is actually absorption to reduce standing waves and other resonances in a room. It converts sound into tiny amounts of heat. Due to longer wavelengths, this becomes increasingly impractical at lower frequencies, requiring several feet of acoustic treatment for very deep bass.

      Actual soundproofing across a wide range of frequencies requires multiple layers of materials of different densities. For example, various boards and air gaps might be sandwiched with sheets of mass loaded vinyl. This can get expensive quickly.

      Comment

      • Kitten
        Senior Member
        • Jul 2023
        • 548

        #4
        Foam might not work for deeper sounds, but most balloon pops are higher pitched anyway. If a duvet can lower the sound, then foam can only be better. Isn't it also used for ear plugs and ear muffs too? They lower the volume substantially. It won't muffle all the sound, but you'll have the walls of the house too, so it's even quieter for the neighbours.

        Comment

        • JayJay
          Member
          • May 2024
          • 66

          #5
          Agree with Kitten - Most explosions have high and low frequency elements so Foam or stuffing will help, as does anything dense/heavy. 3 sheets of sheetrock/plasterboard then foam insulation inside, then 1 more sheet of sheetrock and you'll dampen 90% of the sound pressure.... plus it's cheap.

          Comment

          • DOA
            Member
            • Apr 2017
            • 69

            #6
            I'm gonna add my 'two cents' here... Ideally, you need to go for the 'room within a room' approach. Two MDF walls, an outer one, then several inches of absorbsion material, then an inner skin of MDF. The tricky part is that there need be minimal points of solid contact between the two skins. Possibble rubber buffer points betweeen any adjoining studs. As for the absorbsion naterial, best stuff I've come across for sound deadening is a dense carpet coated foam like material known as "lead foam". As with anything useful and of high quality it comes with a fairly hefty price tag as it is specialist stuff.

            Hope this is of some use, good luck with the build and let us know how you get on!

            Comment

            • Guest

              #7
              There are lots of different kinds of foam and they behave very differently. The choice of what is sold online is often based on what weighs less or compresses well for shipping. In other words, the opposite of what you want.

              A lot of the effectiveness of earplugs and earmuffs comes from forming an airtight seal that prevents the transmission of sound to the inner ear. The problem you are trying to solve is a different one, unless you are expecting your neighbours to keep their fingers in their ears.

              Larger balloons tend to produce pops with more low frequency content but fortunately those frequencies are still a couple of octaves higher than what studio designers have to contend with.

              Even if your mental images of sheetrock seem to make sense and provide reassurance, there can be annoying edge cases. For example, certain constructions of that type will suddenly decide that they want to behave as a drum or a resonant cavity, potentially making the problem worse. In buildings, rigid elements like steel beams can directly transmit sounds to adjacent rooms or appartments, effectively bypassing cavity walls.



              Comment

              • srob2
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2017
                • 552

                #8
                Material absorbs wavelengths up to 4 times its thickness. You need 6.75 inches for 500Hz for really big balloons. You need 1.7 inches for 2000 Hz, anything thinner won't block much. Use smaller balloons and thicker material rather than worrying about what material you used. Test whatever you come up with by having a friend or pump do a b2p while you are on the other side.

                Comment

                Working...