Bad batch of balloons?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Platonic_Lnr
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2025
    • 308

    Bad batch of balloons?

    I've tried Tuftex, Kalisan, Belbal, Gemar, BSA, and Unique 16"-19" balloons, and have never had a single one spontaneous pop right after blowing one up to its rated size. I've also inflated hundreds of Walmart/Hobby Lobby/Amazon 17"/18" balloons, and have had maybe 3 spontaneously pop (which is likely because I almost always blow them up to 20" since they should be sold as that size).

    However, I got a bunch of standard and crystal Cattex 18"s several months ago, and I've had several of them spontaneously pop after inflating them to their rated size, making them the least reliable medium-sized balloons I've tried.

    That being said, if a good number of balloons from the same bag pop spontaneously right after reaching their rated size (not even overinflating them), is that a sign they're from a bad or old batch?
  • lucid
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2016
    • 1174

    #2
    I'm not sure exactly what it means but I had the exact same experience. Cattex 18s in crystal and metallic. The metallics were far worse. Some of them popped before they even got close to rated size. I've never been a fan of metallics but thought I'd give them another try. I learned just how correct i am that they suck lol.

    The crystals got almost to rated size but would pop spontaneously minutes or hours later if they even had a hint of a neck on them. Obviously this is a no-go.

    For reference I got them from Balloune-QC or Extra Looners from a few months ago. I don't blame this company in any way. The blame falls squarely on Cattex.

    Comment

    • Platonic_Lnr
      Senior Member
      • Mar 2025
      • 308

      #3
      Originally posted by lucid
      The crystals got almost to rated size but would pop spontaneously minutes or hours later if they even had a hint of a neck on them. Obviously this is a no-go.

      For reference I got them from Balloune-QC or Extra Looners from a few months ago. I don't blame this company in any way. The blame falls squarely on Cattex.
      Yes that’s the experience I’ve had with them, especially the Crystal fuchsias. It actually sucks because I pumped to pop one and its neck got MASSIVE. It’s probably the best neck I’ve gotten from any medium size balloon (aside from Kalisan). If they were reliable, they’d probably be my go-to medium sized balloon.

      I got my Cattex 18”s from Bargain Balloons, and at less than $6/pack for 25, I’m guessing they’re old. In fact, I suspect they’re rebranded Belbal 17”s because they have the exact same shape when both inflated and uninflated as the standard and soap crystal BB17”s I have, so I wonder if Cattex is rebranding old batches of crystal Belbal 17”s as their own. The same goes for Cattex 24”s; while I’ve only inflated 2 crystals (one of which spontaneously popped, but then I inflated it to 28”), they’re the same shape as Belbal 24”s.

      Speaking of Balloune-QC, they actually have some crystal Belbal 17”s in stock, which I plan on buying once they have Unique 36” Crystal Reds back in stock. It’ll be interesting to compare them to the Cattex 18”s.

      Comment

      • Dust of the Saturn
        Stretched like space-time
        • Feb 2018
        • 411

        #4
        Originally posted by lucid
        I've never been a fan of metallics but thought I'd give them another try. I learned just how correct i am that they suck lol.
        I highly encourage you to try Kalisan mirror balloons (18 inch to start). You will have your opinion changed. If you ever get some, try and push them to their limits, then go for second inflation.

        These balloons changed the game for me.
        Stretched like space-time

        Comment

        • Helium Guy
          Senior Member
          • Dec 2019
          • 256

          #5
          I had the same experience with my Favorite balloon, Cattex 40-inch Standard Color 5 Fushia and 5 Purple they inflated perfectly but they smelled terribly vs the usual sweet Cattex Balloon smell. It appears it was from the same lot, but different colors.
          I asked ChatGPT any reason for the terrible smell:

          "Why the smell changed
          Cattex latex usually has a clean, slightly rubber-sweet scent when fresh. If you catch a foul or sulfuric note, it can mean:

          Latex oxidation — the balloon sat in warmth or light for a while and the proteins in the rubber began to break down.

          Trapped moisture — a bit of humidity or condensation inside the neck during inflation can speed that up.

          Manufacturing residue — occasionally a balloon comes from a batch with leftover curing agent, which ages badly once inflated."

          Comment

          • lucid
            Senior Member
            • Sep 2016
            • 1174

            #6
            Originally posted by Platonic_Lnr

            Yes that’s the experience I’ve had with them, especially the Crystal fuchsias. It actually sucks because I pumped to pop one and its neck got MASSIVE. It’s probably the best neck I’ve gotten from any medium size balloon (aside from Kalisan). If they were reliable, they’d probably be my go-to medium sized balloon.

            I got my Cattex 18”s from Bargain Balloons, and at less than $6/pack for 25, I’m guessing they’re old. In fact, I suspect they’re rebranded Belbal 17”s because they have the exact same shape when both inflated and uninflated as the standard and soap crystal BB17”s I have, so I wonder if Cattex is rebranding old batches of crystal Belbal 17”s as their own. The same goes for Cattex 24”s; while I’ve only inflated 2 crystals (one of which spontaneously popped, but then I inflated it to 28”), they’re the same shape as Belbal 24”s.

            Speaking of Balloune-QC, they actually have some crystal Belbal 17”s in stock, which I plan on buying once they have Unique 36” Crystal Reds back in stock. It’ll be interesting to compare them to the Cattex 18”s.
            Here's the crazy thing.. I've since ordered some belbal 17s from the same place and they are identical in every way. I'm not sure how one company rates them at 17 and one at 18. Yet, I've not had ANY spontaneous pops from the belbals. Granted I've only used a few so far. The other crazy thing is that I blew them up stupidly big as a test, and none popped. Going on two weeks now and they're still in one piece. When I say I blew them up stupidly big, I mean I blew them up until the neck inflated and then lengthened by over double, became wider and bulged against my fingers which were holding it by the mouthpiece on the blower. I didn't let any air out, but rather mashed the air out of the end to give myself something to tie it off with, which was extremely difficult. After I finally got them tied off I called ravyn down to check them out and said "uuh yeah those are gonna pop any time now." But, they haven't. I'm hoping it's not just a fluke and the Belbal 17s are what the Cattex 18s are supposed to be.

            Comment

            • lucid
              Senior Member
              • Sep 2016
              • 1174

              #7
              Originally posted by Dust of the Saturn

              I highly encourage you to try Kalisan mirror balloons (18 inch to start). You will have your opinion changed. If you ever get some, try and push them to their limits, then go for second inflation.

              These balloons changed the game for me.
              Awesome man I appreciate the recommendation. I'll definitely check them out. I've actually been wanting to try out the Kalisan balloons for quite some time now but the crystals are very elusive for me.

              So are the mirror balloons actually reflective as the name implies? If so that does indeed sound pretty cool. And do they feel somewhat like "normal" latex? I know the metallic/pearlescent balloons I've tried in the past have been less stretchy and had almost a gritty feel to them for lack of a better word.

              Comment

              • Platonic_Lnr
                Senior Member
                • Mar 2025
                • 308

                #8
                Originally posted by lucid

                Here's the crazy thing.. I've since ordered some belbal 17s from the same place and they are identical in every way. I'm not sure how one company rates them at 17 and one at 18. Yet, I've not had ANY spontaneous pops from the belbals. Granted I've only used a few so far. The other crazy thing is that I blew them up stupidly big as a test, and none popped. Going on two weeks now and they're still in one piece. When I say I blew them up stupidly big, I mean I blew them up until the neck inflated and then lengthened by over double, became wider and bulged against my fingers which were holding it by the mouthpiece on the blower. I didn't let any air out, but rather mashed the air out of the end to give myself something to tie it off with, which was extremely difficult. After I finally got them tied off I called ravyn down to check them out and said "uuh yeah those are gonna pop any time now." But, they haven't. I'm hoping it's not just a fluke and the Belbal 17s are what the Cattex 18s are supposed to be.
                I went on a panic buy on balloune-QC after they replied in an email saying they're not restocking Uniques, and while it may have been a poor translation, they said "they're closing operations", so in addition to ordering over a dozen Unique 36"s, I ordered like 40 crystal Belbal 17"s (just reds and oranges). It's good to hear they're much better than the Cattex 18"s, as I really like their shape (and yes I pumped to pop one and it got a stupidly huge neck). And the fact they're identical to the Belbal 17"s must prove they're just old Belbal 17"s that Cattex has rebranded, which may also explain why they're cheap (i.e. a pack of 25 is less than $6 on Bargain Balloons).

                But now that you're saying they're good, lol I'm tempted to order more. It sucks balloune-QC is the only place that sells Belbal 17"s in crystal tone, and it says they're getting low on stock. Same goes for Balloons Online's soap bubble Belbals, which I bought dozens of, but they're now all out of stock.

                Comment

                • Dust of the Saturn
                  Stretched like space-time
                  • Feb 2018
                  • 411

                  #9
                  Originally posted by lucid

                  Awesome man I appreciate the recommendation. I'll definitely check them out. I've actually been wanting to try out the Kalisan balloons for quite some time now but the crystals are very elusive for me.

                  So are the mirror balloons actually reflective as the name implies? If so that does indeed sound pretty cool. And do they feel somewhat like "normal" latex? I know the metallic/pearlescent balloons I've tried in the past have been less stretchy and had almost a gritty feel to them for lack of a better word.
                  The space grey color actually looks almost exactly like my fridge lol. Other colors have that reflectiveness but not like a mirror; it's blurry, but still shiny. As for the latex; while inflated they feel extremely bouncy and even though you push them to their limits and they get rock hard, give them 1 hour and the latex relaxes and gets bouncy again. You can do this many many times before failure. They are super strong too.

                  You're right that they feel a little different but nothing like the cheap metallic ones that get rock hard very fast and then pop with no stretch. The kalisan ones are the complete opposite: they stretch so much to the point where deflating them will net you a gigantic piece of latex, kinda like tuftex if done right.

                  They're also very slippery so gripping them with your hands is tough but also challenging in a fun way.

                  20250813_232724.jpg
                  20250813_232745.png

                  (Pic 1 without flash, second with flash, just to show reflectiveness of light) 18 inch in the pics.


                  I was absolutely shocked when I first saw how cool this looked! fits the definition of "Metallic" so well! Looks just like my fridge!

                  You HAVE to give them a try! They're stretchier than any other balloon, you WILL be surprised! They get loooong necks too!




                  ​
                  Stretched like space-time

                  Comment

                  • Dust of the Saturn
                    Stretched like space-time
                    • Feb 2018
                    • 411

                    #10
                    here's another pic in low light.
                    20251022_205107.png

                    Gorgeous isn't it?
                    Stretched like space-time

                    Comment

                    Working...