Is it ok for you to involve others in your fetish without telling them?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • srob2
    Senior Member
    • Dec 2017
    • 552

    #31
    Secretly manipulating anyone tends to be creepy, which I already said is not okay. I'd say if someone has any sexual feelings towards children, anything they do to strengthen that is not okay as it could lead to serious problems in the future.

    Generally, children, men and old or ugly women aren't a turn on for me no matter what they do. But if a bunch of bikini-wearing 17 year old girls asked me to join a balloon blowing contest, I'd probably decline.

    Comment

    • AJK64
      Moderator
      • Jun 2018
      • 1280

      #32
      Originally posted by Merl
      For the approximately 28% who defend it as okay, please explain something:

      What about someone who "creates situations where other people would please your balloon/inflatable kink without knowing what this means for you," except they aren't manipulating adults, they're manipulating children?

      The person gives no clue that they're getting off on this. No visible arousal. No photo or video is attempted. No one could prove there was anything sexual about it. Though others may suspect, they could never prove gratification, voyeurism, or anything.

      So explain, please, what would the difference be between that person secretly manipulating adults with balloons, and secretly manipulating kids with balloons, for the same reason?

      Or IS there a difference, in your opinion?
      Sexual anything involving kids is always non consensual. Sexual urges involving kids regardless of context is very different than any sexual fantasy regarding adults... The fact that this needs explaining to you is... Concerning Merl :/
      Last edited by AJK64; 12-07-2025, 19:58.

      Comment

      • AlterPlatzer
        Senior Member
        • Jun 2024
        • 1528

        #33
        When balloons are involved, all women are beautiful.

        Rd92mco.jpg
        It's OK to love balloons.
        There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

        Comment

        • Guest

          #34
          1. We're not talking about fantasies. The OP specified a real world, real time situation where others are unknowingly being manipulated, not fantasies.

          2. Since you brought it up, ALL fantasies are non-consensual when you get right down to it.

          3. It was you who said morality is "personal" (subjective), thus you claimed,

          I don't think there is a fundamentally "this is right or this is wrong" case to be made.
          Oh really? Then why did you just make a judgment that manipulating children is wrong?

          Of course I agree that IT IS WRONG. I believe that as strongly as anyone here, as I've said before (you know this). I'll go so far as to call it EVIL.

          But when YOU say the OP scenario can't be judged as wrong when involving adults, but IS wrong when involving kids...that's not consistent. You just made the very judgment you said can't be made.

          ​​​​No one can play both sides here. If one scenario is morally wrong (and you're 100% right, it is), then logically both must be wrong.

          Comment

          • AJK64
            Moderator
            • Jun 2018
            • 1280

            #35
            When I said
            I don't think there is a fundamentally "this is right or this is wrong" case to be made.

            It was very obviously relating to this topic which was obviously related to adults.

            Children cannot consent to anything, adults can.

            Fantasies are not real, but I would worry about anyone fantasising about children.

            As I say, if you cannot see the difference between ANY situation related to a kink that involves adults vs children then you are extremely worrying.

            Stop muddying the waters. You are a trouble maker. We gave you a temporary ban once before. Next time it definitely won't be temporary. Stop now. And I do mean now...

            Comment

            • Guest

              #36


              ​​​
              Originally posted by AJK64
              Children cannot consent to anything, adults can.
              Why do you keep bringing up consent?

              ​​Consent has nothing to do with the OP. In fact, the OP avoids consent by specifically asking about something no one can consent to because THEY DON'T KNOW what you're really doing.

              Fantasies are not real, but I would worry about anyone fantasising about children.
              Same! 👍🏻 But again, the OP wasn't asking about fantasy. He asked about real world action where one party is ignorant of your intent.

              As I say, if you cannot see the difference between ANY situation related to a kink that involves adults vs children then you are extremely worrying.
              Please stop misrepresenting the point I made. That isn't true and it isn't fair because I know you will agree that since it IS wrong to trick a kid into sexual stuff (and it is VERY wrong), then it has to be just as wrong to trick an adult into it.

              DECEPTION IS NEVER GOOD, AND THE OP IS ALL ABOUT DECEPTION.

              Good talking with you.

              Comment

              • Guest

                #37
                AKJ is a petty, slow-witted punk who will now delete where I've kicked his ass, like he always does.

                Comment

                • Guest

                  #38
                  So long, everybody else! 🙂

                  Comment

                  • AJK64
                    Moderator
                    • Jun 2018
                    • 1280

                    #39
                    For thoae who are curious. I banned Merl for sending me the most ridiculous, homophobic private message, riddled with gay insults and accusations about mine and other gay people sexual preferences etc. I would post it here but the language used was pretty unbelievable. Although I'm not gay (I'm bi), such language and unhinged vitriol can't be tolerated. We mods have given him so many chances over the years despite receiving numerous complaints from other users about him. But he's gone now, and any sign of him creating another account will also be instantly banned.

                    So he's definitely not a victim here despite what he might want anyone to think
                    Last edited by AJK64; 12-07-2025, 22:31.

                    Comment

                    • lucid
                      Senior Member
                      • Sep 2016
                      • 1174

                      #40
                      Originally posted by AJK64
                      For thoae who are curious. I banned Merl for sending me the most ridiculous, homophobic private message, riddled with gay insults and accusations about mine and other gay people sexual preferences etc. I would post it here but the language used was pretty unbelievable. Although I'm not gay (I'm bi), such language and unhinged vitriol can't be tolerated. We mods have given him so many chances over the years despite receiving numerous complaints from other users about him. But he's gone now, and any sign of him creating another account will also be instantly banned.

                      So he's definitely not a victim here despite what he might want anyone to think
                      Wow that's crazy bro. And all over a petty disagreement about a hypothetical situation. People are so quick to fling crap all over each other. I just don't get it. Obviously you didn't deserve whatever he said to you.
                      We all appreciate everything you do.

                      Comment

                      • AJK64
                        Moderator
                        • Jun 2018
                        • 1280

                        #41
                        Originally posted by lucid

                        Wow that's crazy bro. And all over a petty disagreement about a hypothetical situation. People are so quick to fling crap all over each other. I just don't get it. Obviously you didn't deserve whatever he said to you.
                        We all appreciate everything you do.
                        Thanks man. I have honestly never read anything so venomously homphobic in my entire life haha. It was unhinged.

                        The guy was trouble. He always has been. Disagreeing with what someone writes is great, and leads to discussion, but attacking anyone and trying to act like some kink police is the opposite of what forums like this are for. Especially when talking about hypothetical thought experiments like this topic.

                        Comment

                        • lucid
                          Senior Member
                          • Sep 2016
                          • 1174

                          #42
                          Originally posted by AJK64

                          Thanks man. I have honestly never read anything so venomously homphobic in my entire life haha. It was unhinged.

                          The guy was trouble. He always has been. Disagreeing with what someone writes is great, and leads to discussion, but attacking anyone and trying to act like some kink police is the opposite of what forums like this are for. Especially when talking about hypothetical thought experiments like this topic.
                          Yeah that's really the craziest part. It was all over a situation that isn't even real! There's got to be some other issues swirling around in his noggin. You could have just been the guy that he unloaded on for who knows what. Doesn't make it ok obviously. Probably the most disproportionate reaction I've ever heard of.

                          Comment

                          • Scooter
                            風船天才
                            • May 2022
                            • 497

                            #43
                            Some people will find anything to be upset about. Sorry you had to go through that, AJK.

                            Comment

                            • CronchyHmmmm
                              Silly idiot
                              • Jun 2024
                              • 28

                              #44
                              How this thread went from a simple question, to full blown chaos like we're in fucking kindergarden, and asking what's the difference between involving unsuspecting adults or unsuspecting children into fetish activities, is one of the biggest reasons why I am so deeply ashamed and disgusted and why I want to get rid of this fetish. Some of ya'll make me fucking sick.

                              Edit: This will sound mean but I'm glad at least the person who made me feel sick the most got banned
                              Last edited by CronchyHmmmm; 13-07-2025, 16:13.

                              Comment

                              • AlterPlatzer
                                Senior Member
                                • Jun 2024
                                • 1528

                                #45
                                There's a related question that's as old as the online discussion of having a balloon fetish. It even predates the term looner which appeared around the year 2000.

                                Is there an obligation not to look at something as sexually arousing because it was never intended to be sexually arousing?

                                History Lesson:

                                Until the late 1990s, there was hardly any balloon fetish porn. What was around was either homemade or scans from ordinary porn magazines where balloons just happened to be in a particular photo set.

                                For years, it was almost a sort of competitive sport to search for, download and share any and all pictures and video of people interacting with balloons. There weren't a lot of scruples about what got shared in the balloon fetish community.

                                Since balloons aren't even remotely sexual for the vast majority of the population, some people would take issue with this practice. It seemed this came mostly from non-looners that stumbled upon the balloon fetish community.

                                So, from time to time, people would raise the argument that it was immoral to be getting off to pictures and video that were never intended to be sexually arousing. Usually to the tune of: "how would this person feel if they found out you were getting off to pictures of their cherished family moments?" The general response was: "hey, they posted the picture, it's on them, not me."

                                There was no regard to how old the people in the pictures were. All that mattered was that there were balloons in the picture. This sort of exploded around the year 2000 when one of the more prolific sharers of balloon pictures (allegedly) got his house raided by police looking for you know what. There is conjecture that this raid never actually happened, but it became widely known in the balloon fetish community. After that, even though it remained OK to share whatever random pictures one found online, sharing non-nude pictures of minors became widely frowned upon.

                                Nowadays, there's also a bit of social engineering going on out there.

                                I've seen instances on YouTube where people have encouraged creators to unknowingly make balloon fetish videos. One of the more memorable examples was a woman that got conned into making balloon videos. She made quite few balloon videos over the course of a few years until someone spilled the beans in the comments that this was a fetish. She abruptly stopped making videos and hasn't posted anything on YouTube since then.

                                Without going into too much detail, I will say that this sort of social engineering is not bounded by the age of the creators.

                                Collecting random pictures and videos of people having fun with balloons is probably OK. Whether or not the person(s) in the picture(s) knows the picture is arousing to someone is sort of immaterial. If they had known in advance that the picture(s) would be sexually arousing to someone, would they have posted the picture(s)? There's no way of knowing for certain, but since most people don't regard balloons to be sexually arousing, they probably didn't.

                                Social-engineering people into unknowingly making balloon fetish content is not OK.

                                Making balloons available to random people is OK. If you were to stand on the sidewalk with a big bunch of helium balloons and offer a free balloon to whoever wanted one, that would probably be OK. Having a confederate nearby with camera capturing the moment is probably not OK. Encouraging the recipients of the balloons to do specific things with those balloons is also probably not OK.
                                It's OK to love balloons.
                                There are as many differences in preferences as there colors of balloons. Accentuate what makes us the same and not what sets us apart.

                                Comment

                                Working...