Informal Balloon Fetish Study

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • inconspicuous
    Junior Member
    • Feb 2019
    • 10

    Informal Balloon Fetish Study

    Here's a little informal university study on balloon fetishism from 2012. It doesn't perform any experiments; it simply aggregates survey results into some nice charts.

    Have any of you seen this study before? How do you feel about its findings (do they accurately reflect the community)?

    One metric that caught my eye was how high the ratio of poppers to non-poppers was. I wonder if this is an accurate reflection of the community or if there's a hidden bias like poppers being more extroverted and thus more willing to participate in a study (not saying this is the case; it's just an example)?

    I think it's a real shame that academia has largely ignored this fetish, though I can't say I'm surprised either given how few of us there seems to be. Perhaps it'd be better to generalize and look into studies that revolve around object sexuality as a whole. (Would balloon fetishism be considered object sexuality?) Regardless, if anyone knows of any other studies, formal and informal alike, I'm sure many of us would be interested to read about them.
  • BalloonBoyUK
    Banned
    • Dec 2018
    • 499

    #2
    Re: Informal Balloon Fetish Study

    That "study" is a very poor one, I'm afraid. It only uses 46 people in the "study". No scientific "study" would ever use Wikipedia as a point of reference, nor use online forums as evidence to support/disprove a claim.

    The ratio of poppers to non-poppers is also iffy, as there are plenty of looners who would describe themselves as semi-popper, and thus, if you are a semi-popper, how do you break that down into one of either just a popper or just a non-popper? It's a mess study.

    As for academia "ignoring" the fetish, it hasn't. It's just there are more important subjects that have been studied, that will offer more significant results to the world of science and human biology, than this one does. You have to remember that studies don't get created for fun. A proper academic "study" has to be worthwhile, and come back with something that will revitalise, and invigorate debate into the academic community. Simply producing a study that says there are X number of looners, of which Y are non-poppers and Z are poppers, doesn't do anything for anyone.

    In academia, you can't just decide to study a topic. Your research/study has to be likely to result in something substantial and worthwhile. Asking for people with the fetish to reply to an online questionnaire,7 simply won't "cut the mustard", I'm afraid, in academia. It would barely past muster for a high-school student study.

    The nearest you're going to get to an academic study on balloons, is via studies on BDSM, and the relation to why people chose certain fetishes over others, and how that relates to the Human Condition, and what that means for those who do BDSM. In Academia, the numbers of people who do something is not as important, as the why people do (or don't do) something.

    There is this...



    ...but even this isn't really a true academic study of the world of balloon fetishism.

    Simply put, I doubt any university of any worth would allow someone to do a study on looners, unless it was going to offer something really ground-breaking into our understanding of why people are the way they are, or breaks boundaries into the understanding of human beings.

    Comment

    • Big Balloons!
      Member
      • Jul 2016
      • 80

      #3
      Re: Informal Balloon Fetish Study

      Originally posted by BalloonBoyUK
      That "study" is a very poor one, I'm afraid. It only uses 46 people in the "study". No scientific "study" would ever use Wikipedia as a point of reference, nor use online forums as evidence to support/disprove a claim.

      The ratio of poppers to non-poppers is also iffy, as there are plenty of looners who would describe themselves as semi-popper, and thus, if you are a semi-popper, how do you break that down into one of either just a popper or just a non-popper? It's a mess study.

      As for academia "ignoring" the fetish, it hasn't. It's just there are more important subjects that have been studied, that will offer more significant results to the world of science and human biology, than this one does. You have to remember that studies don't get created for fun. A proper academic "study" has to be worthwhile, and come back with something that will revitalise, and invigorate debate into the academic community. Simply producing a study that says there are X number of looners, of which Y are non-poppers and Z are poppers, doesn't do anything for anyone.

      In academia, you can't just decide to study a topic. Your research/study has to be likely to result in something substantial and worthwhile. Asking for people with the fetish to reply to an online questionnaire,7 simply won't "cut the mustard", I'm afraid, in academia. It would barely past muster for a high-school student study.

      The nearest you're going to get to an academic study on balloons, is via studies on BDSM, and the relation to why people chose certain fetishes over others, and how that relates to the Human Condition, and what that means for those who do BDSM. In Academia, the numbers of people who do something is not as important, as the why people do (or don't do) something.

      There is this...



      ...but even this isn't really a true academic study of the world of balloon fetishism.

      Simply put, I doubt any university of any worth would allow someone to do a study on looners, unless it was going to offer something really ground-breaking into our understanding of why people are the way they are, or breaks boundaries into the understanding of human beings.
      Well explained. There isn't really anything to study for balloon fetishism that wouldn't be done for fetishes in general. The sourcing of Wikipedia and the small sample size struck me as odd.

      The statistics are still interesting and it would be good to have a more up to date set of results using a wider sample size, especially for how comfortable looners feel with their fetish and how it is known to others, themselves etc.
      I think these questionnaire ideas have been explored again recently, not entirely sure

      Comment

      • snh61
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2017
        • 133

        #4
        Re: Informal Balloon Fetish Study

        I have quit trying to read the graphs. Blue bars with blue bars with blue bars on blue background.

        They would kick your ass hard for this round here in any school, including high school.

        Comment

        • t17forLife
          Senior Member
          • May 2015
          • 226

          #5
          Re: Informal Balloon Fetish Study

          I saw this study long before this post, and I agree with many of the criticisms here. In light of that, I'd like to put faces and names together.

          This was done by my friend Pattie Crider. She did this for a professional writing course while going back to school a few years ago. That blog site contains some of her personal stories of being a looner. Those facts aside, the comments made before me still apply.

          There was a small online video series about a year back which interviewed people with "odd" interests or hobbies. Ms. Crider was actually in the 1st episode! Here is the link:



          While this episode was only seen by several thousand people, there is something unique about it. Unlike more mainstream TV outlets, this show approached the topic with much less bias. My late friend Chris Burney was featured on the TLC show Strange Sex in 2009. The founder of Nordic Looners, Dennis, was on a Discovery show in 2012. The same year, two people were featured in a show called Taboo; Domina Elle, a sex worker, and another guy named Dave were featured. In 2014, VICE did an episode with TheGrimLooner (Hi!). In the last few years, small media outlets have done similar things.

          What do they all have in common? All of the features which I've seen attempt to paint us in a negative light, regardless of what they say on the show. They do this by selecting the right looner.

          People like Chris and Dennis, while great people whom I highly respect, do not meet the appearance of an "average" person, personality wise. Furthermore, folks like Dave and fireloon take a less sexual approach to the balloons, but seem to come off as "weird" in the sense of they might have a condition like Asperger's. I believe that these producers seek out the "odd" members of our community intentionally. The VICE episode in 2014 and again in 2016 with another person were some of the very few which I thought were accurate. The big companies like TLC and Discovery added too much pseudoscience and portrayed us in too negatively.

          In fact, I saw someone make a video mocking Chris in the TLC feature, like full on attacking every small detail. That's not cool in the slightest, but at least the big TV networks are better than that.

          Getting back to my point, I was happy to see a much more neutral interview, in addition to the producers choosing a person who represents the "average person" in our society (at least the majority of the United States middle class).

          Comment

          • BalloonBoyUK
            Banned
            • Dec 2018
            • 499

            #6
            Re: Informal Balloon Fetish Study

            Originally posted by t17forLife
            All of the features which I've seen attempt to paint us in a negative light, regardless of what they say on the show. They do this by selecting the right looner.
            Sadly, that is the nature of TV networks. They don't want to have a TV show that says to people "Enjoying balloons, being whipped, being dominated, (or whatever other kink you enjoy) can just be fun, and part of a healthy adult sex life", they want it to always be seen as weird, wrong, freaky, etc, etc. This is why I would NEVER, EVER partake in any kind of public dissection of our fetish, as I would never trust the person/company making the documentary. Once it's unleashed onto the world, like the National Geographic's TABOO episode, the damage is done.

            In fact, Domina Elle did a video lambasting National Geographic for this very reason, which you can see here...



            If I had been Dave, I'd have been f***ing furious with the way they'd portrayed me. So, God-knows how he actually did feel. I bet he was very pissed, to say the least?!

            Comment

            Working...